I have a Datetime object and I want to remove time part from it. I tried the following line of code but still auth.dob contains time. How can I just set 2017-01-01 in it?
auth.dob = Convert.ToDateTime("2017-01-01").Date;
Sadly .Net does not include a type that only stores the date. Generally we use DateTime and set the time to midnight. Then when you output the value you just omit the Time when displaying it see DateTime.ToString(string), DateTime.ToShortDateString() and DateTime.ToLongDateString().
While this works it does lead to all sorts of confusion. I've often felt it would have been better to have a Date struct a Time struct and a DateTime struct that was a composition of the other two. But sadly that isn't the case.
There is the Noda Time library, but that is probably overkill in this case.
Alternatively you can role your own and store the day, month and year as separate numeric variables.
I cannot find any elaboration on why the Date property of the DateTime object is defaulted to midnight. I know that it is, through my own work as well as MSDN, but I am trying to understand the reasoning behind this. I cannot find any articles elaborating on why this is so.
Edit: To elaborate on some of the points being asked in comments.
string a = "2014-10-22 09:00 PM";
DateTime d = DateTime.Parse(a);
In this example I would have assumed it would default to 21:00:00.000- again I know it does not.
DateTime.Date means the day, the same way DateTime.Today returns the current date's DateTime at midnight (as opposed to DateTime.Now). So what do you expect it to return instead? A DateTime is a struct which always contains a time even if it's set to 0:00:00.
So every DateTime has a time component. It's the same as if you'd say: give me an hour without minutes. Every hour can also be represented by 60 minutes. By using dt.Date you say explicitly that you want that DateTime "without" time which means midnight and is a shortcut for new DateTime(dt.Year,dt.Month,dt.Day).
As far as I'm aware, aside from being the start of the date, it's there so you can ignore the Time part of the DateTime.
I'm sure there's better, more detailed explanations (and I'm sure someone, somewhere will come along and mention the use of NodaTime - possibly Jon Skeet himself - and it's Date class)
Because it's got to be set to something, and midnight (ie all zeros) is as good a value as any!
Seriously though, it makes sense at you've asked for a date, and 00:00:00 is the start of that date. There's no Date type in the framework, the designers overloaded DateTime to cover both, and midnight was chosen as the time in the day.
I am working on an application that needs to set rules for periods of time. The company has different branches, each branch can set its own rules (i.e a branch starts work at 8.30 am, ends work at 17.30 pm, with 30 minutes pause for lunch; another branch start at 9.00, ends at 19.00 with 1 hour pause...)
So I need to define a class (let's call it WorkingDayDefinition for the moment) where start and end are not actually a DateTime, because they are not referred to any specific day in particular.
At the moment the only option I see in C# is using Timespan for setting a duration from the beginning of the day, so that 8.30 pm would be TimeSpan(8,30,0) to be added to the Day part of whichever day.
Is this a best practice in C#?
I searched for third parties libraries that could help me, but so far my best bet is this one:
http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/168662/Time-Period-Library-for-NET
that is not strictly what I need
You could use Noda Time. It provides a LocalTime (see here):
LocalTime is an immutable struct representing a time of day, with no reference to a particular calendar, time zone or date.
For 8.30 you would do something like:
LocalTime openingAt = new LocalTime(8, 30);
To me TimeSpam seems very suitable for what you want. It holds an interval of time, sometimes between two events, but in your case between the start of the day and the time you start/finish work. There is no reason I can think of not to use it just because the name might suggest this wasn't the original intention of the class. Plus it already integrates well with DateTimes for any time calculations you need to do later on down the road.
I would like to know how to store time in C# and T-SQL. I know that both of them provide a DateTime type but I just need to store a time. For instance:
var startTime = 9PM;
var endTime = 10PM;
And then store/retrieve this values from a database. Thanks in advance.
Francesco
C#
Whether to use a DateTime or TimeSpan type in C# to store 9 PM is up to taste. Personally, I'd use DateTime, leaving the date component empty, since that's semantically closer to what you want. (A TimeSpan is designed to hold time intervals, such as "21 hours".)
The documentation supports both options. This is from the documentation of TimeSpan:
The TimeSpan structure can also be used to represent the time of day, but only if the time is unrelated to a particular date.
On the other hand, the MSDN article Choosing Between DateTime, DateTimeOffset, and TimeZoneInfo mentions the following:
The DateTime structure is suitable for applications that do the following:
* Work with dates only.
* Work with times only.
[...]
T-SQL
SQL Server has a time data type.
In C# there is not a type to hold only a time. There is TimeSpan, but it's intended to keep a period of time and not really a component of a DateTime (i.e. hours and minutes) only.
Starting with SQL Server 2008 there is a time type (Using Date and Time Data) that does only store a time component.
EDIT: Misread your question at first. TimeSpan is exactly what you're looking for and it can be stored in a time type with SQL 2K8.
In C# you'd probably want to use a TimeSpan structure if you just wanted to store a time interval. However, you seem to want to appear to store a start-time and an end-time, which would require storing two values. You could, therefore, use two TimeSpans (based on, say, number of minutes from midnight to represent the time) or you could just use two DateTime values and throw away the date component.
As has been noted, SQL Server 2008 has a Time datatype, but this isn't available in earlier versions which only have DateTime. You could also just store an Int representing number of minutes past midnight which can be easily converted to a TimeSpan (TimeSpan interval = TimeSpan.FromMinutes(60)).
Timespan in c# is how you manipulate time intervals. Contrary to what other posters are saying i don't think the Time data type is correct for storing time intervals in SQL, unless you actually want to store the start time and end time and not the time interval (i.e. 1 hour in you example). It is for storing a time of day, a bit like a DateTime but with no date. When i want to store a time interval in SQL I just use an int and then have it represent a unit of time appropriate to what I am trying to do (e.g.minutes, seconds, milliseconds etc. )
In our C# project we have the need for representing a date without a time.
I know of the existence of the DateTime, however, it incorporates a time of day as well.
I want to make explicit that certain variables and method-arguments are date-based.
Hence I can't use the DateTime.Date property
What are the standard approaches to this problem?
Why is there no Date class in C#?
Does anyone have a nice implementation using a struct and maybe some extensionmethods on DateTime and maybe implementing some operators such as == and <, > ?
Allow me to add an update to this classic question:
DateOnly (and TimeOnly) types have been added to .NET 6, starting with Preview 4. See my other answer here.
Jon Skeet's Noda Time library is now quite mature, and has a date-only type called LocalDate. (Local in this case just means local to someone, not necessarily local to the computer where the code is running.)
I've studied this problem significantly, so I'll also share several reasons for the necessity of these types:
There is a logical discrepancy between a date-only, and a date-at-midnight value.
Not every local day has a midnight in every time zone. Example: Brazil's spring-forward daylight saving time transition moves the clock from 11:59:59 to 01:00:00.
A date-time always refers to a specific time within the day, while a date-only may refer to the beginning of the day, the end of the day, or the entire range of the day.
Attaching a time to a date can lead to the date changing as the value is passed from one environment to another, if time zones are not watched very carefully. This commonly occurs in JavaScript (whose Date object is really a date+time), but can easily happen in .NET also, or in the serialization as data is passed between JavaScript and .NET.
Serializing a DateTime with XML or JSON (and others) will always include the time, even if it's not important. This is very confusing, especially considering things like birth dates and anniversaries, where the time is irrelevant.
Architecturally, DateTime is a DDD value-object, but it violates the Single Responsibly Principle in several ways:
It is designed as a date+time type, but often is used as date-only (ignoring the time), or time-of-day-only (ignoring the date). (TimeSpan is also often used for time-of-day, but that's another topic.)
The DateTimeKind value attached to the .Kind property splits the single type into three, The Unspecified kind is really the original intent of the structure, and should be used that way. The Utc kind aligns the value specifically with UTC, and the Local kind aligns the value with the environment's local time zone.
The problem with having a separate flag for kind is that every time you consume a DateTime, you are supposed to check .Kind to decide what behavior to take. The framework methods all do this, but others often forget. This is truly a SRP violation, as the type now has two different reasons to change (the value, and the kind).
The two of these lead to API usages that compile, but are often nonsensical, or have strange edge cases caused by side effects. Consider:
// nonsensical, caused by mixing types
DateTime dt = DateTime.Today - TimeSpan.FromHours(3); // when on today??
// strange edge cases, caused by impact of Kind
var london = TimeZoneInfo.FindSystemTimeZoneById("GMT Standard Time");
var paris = TimeZoneInfo.FindSystemTimeZoneById("Romance Standard Time");
var dt = new DateTime(2016, 3, 27, 2, 0, 0); // unspecified kind
var delta = paris.GetUtcOffset(dt) - london.GetUtcOffset(dt); // side effect!
Console.WriteLine(delta.TotalHours); // 0, when should be 1 !!!
In summary, while a DateTime can be used for a date-only, it should only do so when when every place that uses it is very careful to ignore the time, and is also very careful not to try to convert to and from UTC or other time zones.
I suspect there is no dedicate pure Date class because you already have DateTime which can handle it. Having Date would lead to duplication and confusion.
If you want the standard approach look at the DateTime.Date property which gives just the date portion of a DateTime with the time value set to 12:00:00 midnight (00:00:00).
I've emailed refsrcfeedback#microsoft.com and that's their answer
Marcos, this is not a good place to ask questions like these. Try http://stackoverflow.com
Short answer is that you need a model to represent a point in time, and DateTime does that, it’s the most useful scenario in practice. The fact that humans use two concepts (date and time) to mark points in time is arbitrary and not useful to separate.
Only decouple where it is warranted, don’t do things just for the sake of doing things blindly. Think of it this way: what problem do you have that is solved by splitting DateTime into Date and Time? And what problems will you get that you don’t have now? Hint: if you look at DateTime usages across the .NET framework: http://referencesource.microsoft.com/#mscorlib/system/datetime.cs#df6b1eba7461813b#references
You will see that most are being returned from a method. If we didn’t have a single concept like DateTime, you would have to use out parameters or Tuples to return a pair of Date and Time.
HTH,
Kirill Osenkov
In my email I'd questioned if it was because DateTime uses TimeZoneInfo to get the time of the machine - in Now propriety. So I'd say it's because "the business rules" are "too coupled", they confimed that to me.
I created a simple Date struct for times when you need a simple date without worrying about time portion, timezones, local vs. utc, etc.
https://github.com/claycephus/csharp-date
System.DateOnly and System.TimeOnly types were recently added to .NET 6, and are available in the daily builds.
They were included with the .NET 6 Preview 4 release.
See https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/issues/49036
They are in the .NET source code here:
https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/blob/main/src/libraries/System.Private.CoreLib/src/System/DateOnly.cs
https://github.com/dotnet/runtime/blob/main/src/libraries/System.Private.CoreLib/src/System/TimeOnly.cs
I've blogged about them here.
If you need to run date comparisons then use
yourdatetime.Date;
If you are displaying to the screen use
yourdatetime.ToShortDateString();
Allow me to speculate: Maybe it is because until SQL Server 2008 there was no Date datatype in SQL so it would be hard so store it in SQL server?? And it is after all a Microsoft Product?
Who knows why it's that way. There are lots of bad design decisions in the .NET framework. However, I think this is a pretty minor one. You can always ignore the time part, so even if some code does decide to have a DateTime refer to more than just the date, the code that cares should only ever look at the date part. Alternatively, you could create a new type that represents just a date and use functions in DateTime to do the heavy lifting (calculations).
Why? We can only speculate and it doesn't do much to help solve engineering problems. A good guess is that DateTime contains all the functionality that such a struct would have.
If it really matters to you, just wrap DateTime in your own immutable struct that only exposes the date (or look at the DateTime.Date property).
In addition to Robert's answer you also have the DateTime.ToShortDateString method. Also, if you really wanted a Date object you could always use the Adapter pattern and wrap the DateTime object exposing only what you want (i.e. month, day, year).
There is always the DateTime.Date property which cuts off the time part of the DateTime. Maybe you can encapsulate or wrap DateTime in your own Date type.
And for the question why, well, I guess you'll have to ask Anders Heljsberg.
Yeah, also System.DateTime is sealed. I've seen some folks play games with this by creating a custom class just to get the string value of the time as mentioned by earlier posts, stuff like:
class CustomDate
{
public DateTime Date { get; set; }
public bool IsTimeOnly { get; private set; }
public CustomDate(bool isTimeOnly)
{
this.IsTimeOnly = isTimeOnly;
}
public string GetValue()
{
if (IsTimeOnly)
{
return Date.ToShortTimeString();
}
else
{
return Date.ToString();
}
}
}
This is maybe unnecessary, since you could easily just extract GetShortTimeString from a plain old DateTime type without a new class
Because in order to know the date, you have to know the system time (in ticks), which includes the time - so why throw away that information?
DateTime has a Date property if you don't care at all about the time.
If you use the Date or Today properties to get only the date portion from the DateTime object.
DateTime today = DateTime.Today;
DateTime yesterday = DateTime.Now.AddDays(-1).Date;
Then you will get the date component only with the time component set to midnight.