Environment: C#.NET VS 2012
We need to write an order delivery process. Basically it runs through the orders tables and and creates a file every night, that contains orders that are received on that day.
Traditionally we build this using Windows Console Application and a scheduled task wakes up this console application at every night (or every 6 hrs) to deliver the files
We are planning to re-write this console application. We are leaning towards both approaches i.e.
Approach 1: the scheduled task would run to deliver the order every night
Approach 2: ASP.NET web apps, that would also deliver the orders.
I am new to WCF, not yet tried it, is this a good situation to use WCF?
If so, can someone throw me some basic points how to implement this.
FYI: I have implemented another approach for some other client, where we have a ASMX web service that does this job, and the console application just calls the web service.
One disadvantages we have with this approach is, the file creation and delivery and everything is done through IIS and we prefer not to use IIS if it needs to be called from Windows Scheduler. This is for performance reasons.
Thanks
Suresh
Keep it simple. Run a console application as a scheduled task.
An IIS app (WCF service or WebApi) would only be useful if you get job requests, i.e. acting as a server.
Related
I've scenario to create an application(Windows service , Winforms app) which runs twice every day automatically on users PC. These Users are internal employees in the same network. So at morning and evening this application has to run. But it doesn't need to show any window or information saying its running. Its good to have a simple notification in system tray that its started execution.
My experience in with web application development. So I got a little stucked with these such application on deciding which is best.What my understandings are if its a standalone exe, we could ask all users to download the exe and install.
If its a windows service we may depend up on instalutil to install the service.
So I really needs an advice on this. The application is nothing, just requesting a TFS api and the resulting JSON has to store in Table. So the JSOn will be based on each user using their windows authentication.
Please suggest a good solution to achieve its the best,secure and easiest way even for non tech savvy users.
Instead of all user communicating to TFS server twice a day i guess better way is to install a service in one centralized machine which will run a window service twice a day and that machine will host that service using WCF so that other user will communicate with machine this will help you to distribute the load of tfs api. i used the same approach in my case where one machine talk to ALM and other talk to that machine to get the files.
Creating a window service is pretty simple and straight forward.
Follow the link to make one:
https://www.c-sharpcorner.com/UploadFile/naresh.avari/develop-and-install-a-windows-service-in-C-Sharp/
You can host the service in WCF using IIS, TCP, Webservice, Console application its upto you. Follow this link
https://www.codeproject.com/Articles/550796/A-Beginners-Tutorial-on-How-to-Host-a-WCF-Service
I guess i helped you :)
I'm trying to implement a logic for my .NET MVC application where I would trigger scheduled tasks in my application on a following basis:
First scheduled task to run from 00 am to 1 am in the morning
Second scheduled task to run from 1:10 am to 08:00 am in the morning
Third scheduled task to run from 8:15 am to 11:15 pm every 1 hour
This would repeat every day 365 days a year...
Which mechanism in .NET or external library could I use to implement this the easiest way with little code?
I was trying to implement it with Quartz.NET library but I didn't like it at all, I had two scheduled tasks running where one would never run at all for the scheduled time...
You don't want to be performing long running and recurring background tasks in your web application for multiple reasons. You may go through the following blog post which outlines them very well.
I would recommend you moving this logic into a separate Windows Service or even a Console Application whose runs could be scheduled with the Windows Task Scheduler at the desired intervals.
The benefit of this is that you will be off-loading your web application from doing long running tasks which will be consuming precious resources from your webserver. Of course both the webserver and the worker service could share a common centralized datastore or messaging layer in order to communicate if necessary.
For scheduling tasks in ASP.NET MVC you have several options:
3rd party libraries like FluentScheduler, HangFire or Quartz.net.
Since .Net 4.5.2 there is QueueBackgroundWorkItem, a native way to schedule work in the background. Here is a guide on how to use it with ASP.NET MVC.
Azure services for background workloads and scheduled tasks. There are a couple of those aimed at different tasks, here is an overview of them.
Be careful if you try to implement a custom solution yourself, as any exception in a thread not associated with a request would halt the entire process.
Visual Cron is a decent task scheduler you can use. We use it, calling service methods on our asp.net / mvc / webapi servers.
http://www.visualcron.com/
There are some ways that you can create a scheduled task.
1- Create a WebApi and call it by local console or windows service application in period of time.
2- Using 3rd party libraries like FluentScheduler, HangFire or Quartz.net as Andreas said. it has its own side effects though.
3- If Sql server is used in your application, you can create a procedure for your task and put it on a job in Sql server. you can even use C# for your function if CLR is enabled in Sql Server,
If I want to choose, I will choose Sql Server jobs.
I had similar problem with my ASP.NET MVC App, I Wanted to do some works in special times and finally I could find a way.
My solution was Plesk scheduels task feature, as where the most windows servers use plesk control panel You can publish your app on a windows server with plesk CP and create a new actionresualt in your MVC App and write Your codes that want to execute them in special times.
By plesk scheduels tasks create a new task and call your Url with a cron that You made it, You can make many crons.
If I Could not explain It very well You can search about Plesk Schedueled Tasks on the Internet, You can find many good answers.
I have a console application which basically sends emails once per day.
The Windows server administrator disallows this technique and doesn't want to allow extra software on the computer (launched by a scheduled task or a service).
I've been asked to evaluate the possibility of redeveloping a part of the application and integrate it into the IIS application pool but I don't think IIS can do this. Is it possible ? If so, how ?
The only approach I've looked at so far is to redevelop it as a web application and launch a web page everyday with a scheduled task, but I'd like to avoid that.
Let's analyze your options:
Use task scheduler in your server to launch console app
Use task schedule**r in your server to **web service hosted in IIS
Have an IIS application running 100% of time in an infinite loop that that checks time every minute and if it happens to be the correct time send the emails
Have a windows service.
Use task scheduler in a different server to invoke
Analyzing each one of them:
KO: Your administrator does not want console apps and process is not isolated.
KO: You have process isolated but still you are installing a console app.
OK: Not very good for performance but your fulfills your admin conditions.
KO: Your admin does not want windows services.
??: Probably your admin will not want to use an extra server
Proposed solution: As you can see only options 3 and 5 might pass the filter. Ask him
Correct solution I did similar things in the past and went for option 2. You have to convince your admin that solution 3 is a bad idea and probably 5 is already out of the question. When he had to choose the lesser of the evils option 2 is the best :-)
NOTE: You don't mention it but in case you have a SQL Server or similar you can store there an scheduled task too...
I had similar questions when I was moving from Apache servers (where it's dead easy to send a nightly email) to Windows (where you have options).
Clients have sometimes pushed me towards SQL Mail. It's not terrible. If your web app has a SQL backend, and it's okay to schedule things there, it's capable of sending emails when properly configured.
I don't think this is possible. With an IIS application you'd need something to trigger loading the application (call the web page). This itself would require a scheduled task.
You need to pound some sense into your administrator. Sorry.
I am new to WCF and i am designing a project in which i want to run a crawler program (coded in c#) which crawlers some websites and it stores the crawled data in the tables of database (sql server db). I want that crawler runs repeatedly after 30 minutes and updated the database.
I want to then use the service on my hosted platform so that i can use the data from tables in web form (i.e. .aspx page)
Is it okay to use WCF for this purpose ?
Please suggest me how to move on ?
Thanks
Windows Communication Foundation (WCF) is responsible for communication between 2 points with different channel technology. you will use WCF if you want to send/receive some data between two point regardless channel technology (TCP/UDP/NetPipe/MSMQ , ...)
But you first need to design you crawler application which is configured to fetch data from your target web sites, then you need to design a schedular application using
http://quartznet.sourceforge.net/
to run your crawlers.
after running and storing your web pages you can use WCF if you need to do replication or synchronization with center server but it is optional
You could use a WCF service to do this but I would go for another setup:
I'd build a Windows application that is scheduled to run every 30 minutes by the Windows Task Scheduler. A simple console application might be fine.
I'd use a Web application (possibly ASP MVC) to query the database.
As you can see there is no need to use WCF at all.
An exception can/must be made when the server is not yours but you are using a hosting provider who doesn't allow you to schedule a Windows task. In that case you might want to run the crawling process by hand through the web application and have it repeat itself after 30 minutes.
Some hosting providers do allow the scheduling of tasks but in a different way so it might be worth to investigate.
I have a C# application that needs to always be running. I originally planned on making this a windows service but I now have a requirement to make the application host a web admin console.
I haven't played with IIS in quite a few years so my question is this:
What would you recommend I use?
I've thought about making a windows service and embedding a web server such as Cassini but so far I'm not very happy with the open source web servers I've looked at.
Can IIS handle this? Do people use it for this type of scenario, and if so how?
This sounds like a job for two separate projects.
One is the original Windows Service. Windows Services are well suited for what you're doing.
The second is the Web Project that will be used to administer the Windows Service. This is the part that runs in IIS.
It depends on what you mean by always running. An ASP.NET web application deployed in IIS could very well be unloaded by the web server if there aren't any requests for certain amount of time killing all background threads. So if you want an ever running background thread it would be better suited to use a Windows Service. As far as the web admin is concerned, well, here you don't have much choice: ASP.NET in IIS. In order to do something useful those two applications should be able to find a common language to talk. So you could use a database to store the results into which could be used by both applications.
IIS will run your app on first request, not on server boot. So you will still need to run a service to ensure your app is always running.
You can use IIS as a webserver for your web admin part, and link your ASP.net app with your service by means of a configuration database (easy) or webservices (a little more tricky).
Windows and Web services are two very different creatures. A web service will expose external methods that you can implement against an application, while a windows service is an entity within itself. If you're planning on using this service on a timed interval to perform an operation, a Windows service would be the right way to go. If you use a web service, you will need to invoke the method you wish to run from a secondary application.
If you need to queue commands against your windows service, you could always create a database that was accessible by both your website and your windows service. This way you could send commands and query data between the two. Placing a web service in to serve as an intermidary between the two may be overkill.