We Keep Coding

C#: Need to split a string into a string[] and keeping the delimiter (also a string) at the beginning of the string

I think I am too dumb to solve this problem...
I have some formulas which need to be "translated" from one syntax to another.
Let's say I have a formula that goes like that (it's a simple one, others have many "Ceilings" in it):
string formulaString = "If([Param1] = 0, 1, Ceiling([Param2] / 0.55) * [Param3])";
I need to replace "Ceiling()" with "Ceiling(; 1)" (basically, insert "; 1" before the ")").
My attempt is to split the fomulaString at "Ceiling(" so I am able to iterate through the string array and insert my string at the correct index (counting every "(" and ")" to get the right index)
What I have so far:
//splits correct, but loses "CEILING("
string[] parts = formulaString.Split(new[] { "CEILING(" }, StringSplitOptions.None);
//splits almost correct, "CEILING(" is in another group
string[] parts = Regex.Split(formulaString, #"(CEILING\()");
//splits almost every letter
string[] parts = Regex.Split(formulaString, #"(?=[(CEILING\()])");
When everything is done, I concat the string so I have my complete formula again.
What do I have to set as Regex pattern to achieve this sample? (Or any other method that will help me)
part1 = "If([Param1] = 0, 1, ";
part2 = "Ceiling([Param2] / 0.55) * [Param3])";
//part3 = next "CEILING(" in a longer formula and so on...

As I mention in a comment, you almost got it: (?=Ceiling). This is incomplete for your use case unfortunately.
I need to replace "Ceiling()" with "Ceiling(; 1)" (basically, insert "; 1" before the ")").
Depending on your regex engine (for example JS) this works:
string[] parts = Regex.Split(formulaString, #"(?<=Ceiling\([^)]*(?=\)))");
string modifiedFormula = String.join("; 1", parts);
The regex
(?<=Ceiling\([^)]*(?=\)))
(?<= ) Positive lookbehind
Ceiling\( Search for literal "Ceiling("
[^)] Match any char which is not ")" ..
* .. 0 or more times
(?=\)) Positive lookahead for ")", effectively making us stop before the ")"
This regex is a zero-assertion, therefore nothing is lost and it will cut your strings before the last ")" in every "Ceiling()".
This solution would break whenever you have nested "Ceiling()". Then your only solution would be writing your own parser for the same reasons why you can't parse markup with regex.

Regex.Replace(formulaString, #"(?<=Ceiling\()(.*?)(?=\))","$1; 1");
Note: This will not work for nested "Ceilings", but it does for Ceiling(), It will also not work fir Ceiling(AnotherFunc(x)). For that you need something like:
Regex.Replace(formulaString, #"(?<=Ceiling\()((.*\((?>[^()]+|(?1))*\))*|[^\)]*)(\))","$1; 1$3");
but I could not get that to work with .NET, only in JavaScript.

This is my solution:
private string ConvertCeiling(string formula)
{
int ceilingsCount = formula.CountOccurences("Ceiling(");
int startIndex = 0;
int bracketCounter;
for (int i = 0; i < ceilingsCount; i++)
{
startIndex = formula.IndexOf("Ceiling(", startIndex);
bracketCounter = 0;
for (int j = 0; j < formula.Length; j++)
{
if (j < startIndex) continue;
var c = formula[j];
if (c == '(')
{
bracketCounter++;
}
if (c == ')')
{
bracketCounter--;
if (bracketCounter == 0)
{
// found end
formula = formula.Insert(j, "; 1");
startIndex++;
break;
}
}
}
}
return formula;
}
And CountOccurence:
public static int CountOccurences(this string value, string parameter)
{
int counter = 0;
int startIndex = 0;
int indexOfCeiling;
do
{
indexOfCeiling = value.IndexOf(parameter, startIndex);
if (indexOfCeiling < 0)
{
break;
}
else
{
startIndex = indexOfCeiling + 1;
counter++;
}
} while (true);
return counter;
}

Using a for loop to iterate from an array to a list

I have a text file that is divided up into many sections, each about 10 or so lines long. I'm reading in the file using File.ReadAllLines into an array, one line per element of the array, and I'm then I'm trying to parse each section of the file to bring back just some of the data. I'm storing the results in a list, and hoping to export the list to csv ultimately.
My for loop is giving me trouble, as it loops through the right amount of times, but only pulls the data from the first section of the text file each time rather than pulling the data from the first section and then moving on and pulling the data from the next section. I'm sure I'm doing something wrong either in my for loop or for each loop. Any clues to help me solve this would be much appreciated! Thanks
David
My code so far:
namespace ParseAndExport
{
class Program
{
static readonly string sourcefile = #"Path";
static void Main(string[] args)
{
string[] readInLines = File.ReadAllLines(sourcefile);
int counter = 0;
int holderCPStart = counter + 3;//Changed Paths will be an different number of lines each time, but will always start 3 lines after the startDiv
/*Need to find the start of the section and the end of the section and parse the bit in between.
* Also need to identify the blank line that occurs in each section as it is essentially a divider too.*/
int startDiv = Array.FindIndex(readInLines, counter, hyphens72);
int blankLine = Array.FindIndex(readInLines, startDiv, emptyElement);
int endDiv = Array.FindIndex(readInLines, counter + 1, hyphens72);
List<string> results = new List<string>();
//Test to see if FindIndexes work. Results should be 0, 7, 9 for 1st section of sourcefile
/*Console.WriteLine(startDiv);
Console.WriteLine(blankLine);
Console.WriteLine(endDiv);*/
//Check how long the file is so that for testing we know how long the while loop should run for
//Console.WriteLine(readInLines.Length);
//sourcefile has 5255 lines (elements) in the array
for (int i = 0; i <= readInLines.Length; i++)
{
if (i == startDiv)
{
results = (readInLines[i + 1].Split('|').Select(p => p.Trim()).ToList());
string holderCP = string.Join(Environment.NewLine, readInLines, holderCPStart, (blankLine - holderCPStart - 1)).Trim();
results.Add(holderCP);
string comment = string.Join(" ", readInLines, blankLine + 1, (endDiv - (blankLine + 1)));//in case the comment is more than one line long
results.Add(comment);
i = i + 1;
}
else
{
i = i + 1;
}
foreach (string result in results)
{
Console.WriteLine(result);
}
//csvcontent.AppendLine("Revision Number, Author, Date, Time, Count of Lines, Changed Paths, Comments");
/* foreach (string result in results)
{
for (int x = 0; x <= results.Count(); x++)
{
StringBuilder csvcontent = new StringBuilder();
csvcontent.AppendLine(results[x] + "," + results[x + 1] + "," + results[x + 2] + "," + results[x + 3] + "," + results[x + 4] + "," + results[x + 5]);
x = x + 6;
string csvpath = #"addressforcsvfile";
File.AppendAllText(csvpath, csvcontent.ToString());
}
}*/
}
Console.ReadKey();
}
private static bool hyphens72(String h)
{
if (h == "------------------------------------------------------------------------")
{
return true;
}
else
{
return false;
}
}
private static bool emptyElement(String ee)
{
if (ee == "")
{
return true;
}
else
{
return false;
}
}
}
}

It looks like you are trying to grab all of the lines in a file that are not "------" and put them into a list of strings.
You can try this:
var lineswithoutdashes = readInLines.Where(x => x != hyphens72).Select(x => x).ToList();
Now you can take this list and do the split with a '|' to extract the fields you wanted

The logic seems wrong. There are issues with the code in itself also. I am unsure what precisely you're trying to do. Anyway, a few hints that I hope will help:
The if (i == startDiv) checks to see if I equals startDiv. I assume the logic that happens when this condition is met, is what you refer to as "pulls the data from the first section". That's correct, given you only run this code when I equals startDiv.
You increase the counter I inside the for loop, which in itself also increases the counter i.
If the issue in 2. wouldn't exists then I'd suggest to not do the same operation "i = i + 1" in both the true and false conditions of the if (i == startDiv).
Given I assume this file might actually be massive, it's probably a good idea to not store it in memory, but just read the file line by line and process line by line. There's currently no obvious reason why you'd want to consume this amount of memory, unless it's because of the convenience of this API "File.ReadAllLines(sourcefile)". I wouldn't be too scared to read the file like this:
Try (BufferedReader br = new BufferedReader(new FileReader (file))) {
String line;
while ((line = br.readLine()) != null) {
// process the line.
}
}
You can skip the lines until you've passed where the line equals hyphens72.
Then for each line, you process the line with the code you provided in the true case of (i == startDiv), or at least, from what you described, this is what I assume you are trying to do.

int startDiv will return the line number that contains hyphens72.
So your current for loop will only copy to results for the single line that matches the calculated line number.
I guess you want to search the postion of startDiv in the current line?
const string hyphens72;
// loop over lines
for (var lineNumber = 0; lineNumber <= readInLines.Length; lineNumber++) {
string currentLine = readInLines[lineNumber];
int startDiv = currentLine.IndexOf(hyphens72);
// loop over characters in line
for (var charIndex = 0; charIndex < currentLine.Length; charIndex++) {
if (charIndex == startDiv) {
var currentCharacter = currentLine[charIndex];
// write to result ...
}
else {
continue; // skip this character
}
}
}

There are a several things which could be improved.
I would use ReadLines over File.ReadAllLines( because ReadAllLines reads all the lines at ones. ReadLines will stream it.
With the line results = (readInLines[i + 1].Split('|').Select(p => p.Trim()).ToList()); you're overwriting the previous results list. You'd better use results.AddRange() to add new results.
for (int i = 0; i <= readInLines.Length; i++) means when the length = 10 it will do 11 iterations. (1 too many) (remove the =)
Array.FindIndex(readInLines, counter, hyphens72); will do a scan. On large files it will take ages to completely read them and search in it. Try to touch a single line only ones.
I cannot test what you are doing, but here's a hint:
IEnumerable<string> readInLines = File.ReadLines(sourcefile);
bool started = false;
List<string> results = new List<string>();
foreach(var line in readInLines)
{
// skip empty lines
if(emptyElement(line))
continue;
// when dashes are found, flip a boolean to activate the reading mode.
if(hyphens72(line))
{
// flip state.. (start/end)
started != started;
}
if(started)
{
// I don't know what you are doing here precisely, do what you gotta do. ;-)
results.AddRange((line.Split('|').Select(p => p.Trim()).ToList()));
string holderCP = string.Join(Environment.NewLine, readInLines, holderCPStart, (blankLine - holderCPStart - 1)).Trim();
results.Add(holderCP);
string comment = string.Join(" ", readInLines, blankLine + 1, (endDiv - (blankLine + 1)));//in case the comment is more than one line long
results.Add(comment);
}
}
foreach (string result in results)
{
Console.WriteLine(result);
}

You might want to start with a class like this. I don't know whether each section begins with a row of hyphens, or if it's just in between. This should handle either scenario.
What this is going to do is take your giant list of strings (the lines in the file) and break it into chunks - each chunk is a set of lines (10 or so lines, according to your OP.)
The reason is that it's unnecessarily complicated to try to read the file, looking for the hyphens, and process the contents of the file at the same time. Instead, one class takes the input and breaks it into chunks. That's all it does.
Another class might read the file and pass its contents to this class to break them up. Then the output is the individual chunks of text.
Another class can then process those individual sections of 10 or so lines without having to worry about hyphens or what separates on chunk from another.
Now that each of these classes is doing its own thing, it's easier to write unit tests for each of them separately. You can test that your "processing" class receives an array of 10 or so lines and does whatever it's supposed to do with them.
public class TextSectionsParser
{
private readonly string _delimiter;
public TextSectionsParser(string delimiter)
{
_delimiter = delimiter;
}
public IEnumerable<IEnumerable<string>> ParseSections(IEnumerable<string> lines)
{
var result = new List<List<string>>();
var currentList = new List<string>();
foreach (var line in lines)
{
if (line == _delimiter)
{
if(currentList.Any())
result.Add(currentList);
currentList = new List<string>();
}
else
{
currentList.Add(line);
}
}
if (currentList.Any() && !result.Contains(currentList))
{
result.Add(currentList);
}
return result;
}
}

C# How to generate a new string based on multiple ranged index

Let's say I have a string like this one, left part is a word, right part is a collection of indices (single or range) used to reference furigana (phonetics) for kanjis in my word:
string myString = "子で子にならぬ時鳥,0:こ;2:こ;7-8:ほととぎす"
The pattern in detail:
word,<startIndex>(-<endIndex>):<furigana>
What would be the best way to achieve something like this (with a space in front of the kanji to mark which part is linked to the [furigana]):
子[こ]で 子[こ]にならぬ 時鳥[ほととぎす]
Edit: (thanks for your comments guys)
Here is what I wrote so far:
static void Main(string[] args)
{
string myString = "ABCDEF,1:test;3:test2";
//Split Kanjis / Indices
string[] tokens = myString.Split(',');
//Extract furigana indices
string[] indices = tokens[1].Split(';');
//Dictionnary to store furigana indices
Dictionary<string, string> furiganaIndices = new Dictionary<string, string>();
//Collect
foreach (string index in indices)
{
string[] splitIndex = index.Split(':');
furiganaIndices.Add(splitIndex[0], splitIndex[1]);
}
//Processing
string result = tokens[0] + ",";
for (int i = 0; i < tokens[0].Length; i++)
{
string currentIndex = i.ToString();
if (furiganaIndices.ContainsKey(currentIndex)) //add [furigana]
{
string currentFurigana = furiganaIndices[currentIndex].ToString();
result = result + " " + tokens[0].ElementAt(i) + string.Format("[{0}]", currentFurigana);
}
else //nothing to add
{
result = result + tokens[0].ElementAt(i);
}
}
File.AppendAllText(#"D:\test.txt", result + Environment.NewLine);
}
Result:
ABCDEF,A B[test]C D[test2]EF
I struggle to find a way to process ranged indices:
string myString = "ABCDEF,1:test;2-3:test2";
Result : ABCDEF,A B[test] CD[test2]EF

I don't have anything against manually manipulating strings per se. But given that you seem to have a regular pattern describing the inputs, it seems to me that a solution that uses regex would be more maintainable and readable. So with that in mind, here's an example program that takes that approach:
class Program
{
private const string _kinvalidFormatException = "Invalid format for edit specification";
private static readonly Regex
regex1 = new Regex(#"(?<word>[^,]+),(?<edit>(?:\d+)(?:-(?:\d+))?:(?:[^;]+);?)+", RegexOptions.Compiled),
regex2 = new Regex(#"(?<start>\d+)(?:-(?<end>\d+))?:(?<furigana>[^;]+);?", RegexOptions.Compiled);
static void Main(string[] args)
{
string myString = "子で子にならぬ時鳥,0:こ;2:こ;7-8:ほととぎす";
string result = EditString(myString);
}
private static string EditString(string myString)
{
Match editsMatch = regex1.Match(myString);
if (!editsMatch.Success)
{
throw new ArgumentException(_kinvalidFormatException);
}
int ichCur = 0;
string input = editsMatch.Groups["word"].Value;
StringBuilder text = new StringBuilder();
foreach (Capture capture in editsMatch.Groups["edit"].Captures)
{
Match oneEditMatch = regex2.Match(capture.Value);
if (!oneEditMatch.Success)
{
throw new ArgumentException(_kinvalidFormatException);
}
int start, end;
if (!int.TryParse(oneEditMatch.Groups["start"].Value, out start))
{
throw new ArgumentException(_kinvalidFormatException);
}
Group endGroup = oneEditMatch.Groups["end"];
if (endGroup.Success)
{
if (!int.TryParse(endGroup.Value, out end))
{
throw new ArgumentException(_kinvalidFormatException);
}
}
else
{
end = start;
}
text.Append(input.Substring(ichCur, start - ichCur));
if (text.Length > 0)
{
text.Append(' ');
}
ichCur = end + 1;
text.Append(input.Substring(start, ichCur - start));
text.Append(string.Format("[{0}]", oneEditMatch.Groups["furigana"]));
}
if (ichCur < input.Length)
{
text.Append(input.Substring(ichCur));
}
return text.ToString();
}
}
Notes:
This implementation assumes that the edit specifications will be listed in order and won't overlap. It makes no attempt to validate that part of the input; depending on where you are getting your input from you may want to add that. If it's valid for the specifications to be listed out of order, you can also extend the above to first store the edits in a list and sort the list by the start index before actually editing the string. (In similar fashion to the way the other proposed answer works; though, why they are using a dictionary instead of a simple list to store the individual edits, I have no idea…that seems arbitrarily complicated to me.)
I included basic input validation, throwing exceptions where failures occur in the pattern matching. A more user-friendly implementation would add more specific information to each exception, describing what part of the input actually was invalid.
The Regex class actually has a Replace() method, which allows for complete customization. The above could have been implemented that way, using Replace() and a MatchEvaluator to provide the replacement text, instead of just appending text to a StringBuilder. Which way to do it is mostly a matter of preference, though the MatchEvaluator might be preferred if you have a need for more flexible implementation options (i.e. if the exact format of the result can vary).
If you do choose to use the other proposed answer, I strongly recommend you use StringBuilder instead of simply concatenating onto the results variable. For short strings it won't matter much, but you should get into the habit of always using StringBuilder when you have a loop that is incrementally adding onto a string value, because for long string the performance implications of using concatenation can be very negative.

This should do it (and even handle ranged indices), based on the formatting of the input string you have-
using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
public class stringParser
{
private struct IndexElements
{
public int start;
public int end;
public string value;
}
public static void Main()
{
//input string
string myString = "子で子にならぬ時鳥,0:こ;2:こ;7-8:ほととぎす";
int wordIndexSplit = myString.IndexOf(',');
string word = myString.Substring(0,wordIndexSplit);
string indices = myString.Substring(wordIndexSplit + 1);
string[] eachIndex = indices.Split(';');
Dictionary<int,IndexElements> index = new Dictionary<int,IndexElements>();
string[] elements;
IndexElements e;
int dash;
int n = 0;
int last = -1;
string results = "";
foreach (string s in eachIndex)
{
e = new IndexElements();
elements = s.Split(':');
if (elements[0].Contains("-"))
{
dash = elements[0].IndexOf('-');
e.start = int.Parse(elements[0].Substring(0,dash));
e.end = int.Parse(elements[0].Substring(dash + 1));
}
else
{
e.start = int.Parse(elements[0]);
e.end = e.start;
}
e.value = elements[1];
index.Add(n,e);
n++;
}
//this is the part that takes the "setup" from the parts above and forms the result string
//loop through each of the "indices" parsed above
for (int i = 0; i < index.Count; i++)
{
//if this is the first iteration through the loop, and the first "index" does not start
//at position 0, add the beginning characters before its start
if (last == -1 && index[i].start > 0)
{
results += word.Substring(0,index[i].start);
}
//if this is not the first iteration through the loop, and the previous iteration did
//not stop at the position directly before the start of the current iteration, add
//the intermediary chracters
else if (last != -1 && last + 1 != index[i].start)
{
results += word.Substring(last + 1,index[i].start - (last + 1));
}
//add the space before the "index" match, the actual match, and then the formatted "index"
results += " " + word.Substring(index[i].start,(index[i].end - index[i].start) + 1)
+ "[" + index[i].value + "]";
//remember the position of the ending for the next iteration
last = index[i].end;
}
//if the last "index" did not stop at the end of the input string, add the remaining characters
if (index[index.Keys.Count - 1].end + 1 < word.Length)
{
results += word.Substring(index[index.Keys.Count-1].end + 1);
}
//trimming spaces that may be left behind
results = results.Trim();
Console.WriteLine("INPUT - " + myString);
Console.WriteLine("OUTPUT - " + results);
Console.Read();
}
}
input - 子で子にならぬ時鳥,0:こ;2:こ;7-8:ほととぎす
output - 子[こ]で 子[こ]にならぬ 時鳥[ほととぎす]
Note that this should also work with characters the English alphabet if you wanted to use English instead-
input - iliketocodeverymuch,2:A;4-6:B;9-12:CDEFG
output - il i[A]k eto[B]co deve[CDEFG]rymuch

C# For Loop with LIST using LINQ

I'm using LINQ and returning a list to my Business Logic Layer. I'mtrying to change one of the values in the list (changing the 'star' rating to an image with the number of stars).
Although the counter (i) appears to be working, the FOR loop is not working correctly. The first time through it stops at the correct IF but then it pops out at the ELSE statement for everything and all values end up with "star0.png." It appears as though I'm not cycling through the list??? Thanks in advance!
for (int i = 0; i < ReviewList.Count; i++)
{
string serviceCode = ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC;
if (serviceCode == "*")
{
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star1.png";
}
else if (serviceCode == "**")
{
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star2.png";
}
else if (serviceCode == "***")
{
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star3.png";
}
else if (serviceCode == "****")
{
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star4.png";
}
else
{
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star0.png";
}
}

If all values end up at star0.png, then you are cycling through the list. The fact that the else statement is the only code being executed for each element suggests a logical error -- did you perhaps mean to do something like this?
string serviceCode = ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_CODE;

I dont think its an issue of the for loop working properly... your syntax is good and as written will iterate ReviewList.Count # of times.
I would step through and verify the contents of ReviewList first.
Let me know what you find

If you know each item will consist of a number of stars, why not do this?:
for (int i = 0; i < ReviewList.Count; i++)
{
string serviceCode = ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC;
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star" + serviceCode.Length + ".png";
}

Protection on double pass and with else condition
for (int i = 0; i < ReviewList.Count; i++)
{
string serviceCode = ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC;
if(!serviceCode.Contains(".png")) { // once name set should not be modified
if(serviceCode.Contains("*"))
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star" + serviceCode.Length + ".png";
else
ReviewList[i].SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC = "star0.png";
}
}
alternate LINQ approach
ReviewList.ForEach(rs=>if(!rs.SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC.Contains(".png"))
{ rs.SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC =
"star" + rs.SERVICE.SERVICE_DESC.Length + ".png"});

CSV Validation in C# - Making sure each row has the same number of commas

I wish to implement a fairly simple CSV checker in my C#/ASP.NET application - my project automatically generates CSV's from GridView's for users, but I want to be able to quickly run through each line and see if they have the same amount of commas, and throw an exception if any differences occur. So far I have this, which does work but there are some issues I'll describe soon:
int? CommaCount = null;
StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder();
StringWriter sw = new StringWriter(sb);
String Str = null;
//This loops through all the headerrow cells and writes them to the stringbuilder
for (int k = 0; k <= (grd.Columns.Count - 1); k++)
{
sw.Write(grd.HeaderRow.Cells[k].Text + ",");
}
sw.WriteLine(",");
//This loops through all the main rows and writes them to the stringbuilder
for (int i = 0; i <= grd.Rows.Count - 1; i++)
{
StringBuilder RowString = new StringBuilder();
for (int j = 0; j <= grd.Columns.Count - 1; j++)
{
//We'll need to strip meaningless junk such as <br /> and
Str = grd.Rows[i].Cells[j].Text.ToString().Replace("<br />", "");
if (Str == " ")
{
Str = "";
}
Str = "\"" + Str + "\"" + ",";
RowString.Append(Str);
sw.Write(Str);
}
sw.WriteLine();
//The below code block ensures that each row contains the same number of commas, which is crucial
int RowCommaCount = CheckChar(RowString.ToString(), ',');
if (CommaCount == null)
{
CommaCount = RowCommaCount;
}
else
{
if (CommaCount!= RowCommaCount)
{
throw new Exception("CSV generated is corrupt - line " + i + " has " + RowCommaCount + " commas when it should have " + CommaCount);
}
}
}
sw.Close();
And my CheckChar method:
protected static int CheckChar(string Input, char CharToCheck)
{
int Counter = 0;
foreach (char StringChar in Input)
{
if (StringChar == CharToCheck)
{
Counter++;
}
}
return Counter;
}
Now my problem is, if a cell in the grid contains a comma, my check char method will still count these as delimiters so will return an error. As you can see in the code, I wrap all the values in " characters to 'escape' them. How simple would it be to ignore commas in values in my method? I assume I'll need to rewrite the method quite a lot.

var rx = new Regex("^ ( ( \"[^\"]*\" ) | ( (?!$)[^\",] )+ | (?<1>,) )* $", RegexOptions.ExplicitCapture | RegexOptions.IgnorePatternWhitespace | RegexOptions.Multiline);
var matches = rx.Matches("Hello,World,How,Are\nYou,Today,This,Is,\"A beautiful, world\",Hi!");
for (int i = 1; i < matches.Count; i++) {
if (matches[i].Groups[1].Captures.Count != matches[i - 1].Groups[1].Captures.Count) {
throw new Exception();
}
}

You could just use a regular expression that matches one item and count the number of matches in your line. An example of such a regex is the following:
var itemsRegex =
new Regex(#"(?<=(^|[\" + separator + #"]))((?<item>[^""\" + separator +
#"\n]*)|(?<item>""([^""]|"""")*""))(?=($|[\" + separator + #"]))");

Just do something like the following (assuming you don't want to have " inside your fields (otherwise these need some extra handling)):
protected static int CheckChar(string Input, char CharToCheck, char fieldDelimiter)
{
int Counter = 0;
bool inValue = false;
foreach (char StringChar in Input)
{
if (StringChar == fieldDelimiter)
inValue = !inValue;
else if (!inValue && StringChar == CharToCheck)
Counter++;
}
return Counter;
}
This will cause inValue to be true while inside fields. E.g. pass '"' as fieldDelimiter to ignore everything between "...". Just note that this won't handle escaped " (like "" or \"). You'd have to add such handling yourself.

Instead of checking the resulting string (the cake) you should check the fields (ingredients) before you concatenate (mix) them. That would give you the change to do something constructive (escaping/replacing) and throwing an exception only as a last resort.
In general, "," are legal in .csv fields, as long as the string fields are quoted. So internal "," should not be a problem, but the quotes may well be.