Why does the string Remove() method allow a char as a parameter? - c#

Consider this code:
var x = "tesx".Remove('x');
If I run this code, I get this exception:
startIndex must be less than length of string.
Why can I pass a char instead of an int to this method?
Why don't I get a compilation error?
Why does the compiler have this behavior?

you try to remove 'x' which is a declared as char, x is equal to 120
The .Remove only takes 2 parameters of type int the start and (optional) count to remove from the string.
If you pass a char, it will be converted to the integer representation. Meaning if you pass 'x' -> 120 is greater than the string's .Length and that's why it will throw this error!

Implicit conversion lets you compile this code since char can be converted to int and no explicit conversion is required. This will also compile and the answer will be 600 (120*5) -
char c = 'x';
int i = c;
int j = 5;
int answer = i * j;
From MSDN, implicit conversion is summarized as below -
As other's have stated you could use Replace or Remove with valid inputs.

There is no overload of Remove that takes a char, so the character is implicitly converted to an int and the Remove method tries to use it as an index into the string, which is way outside the string. That's why you get that runtime error instead of a compile time error saying that the parameter type is wrong.
To use Remove to remove part of a string, you first need to find where in the string that part is. Example:
var x = "tesx";
var x = x.Remove(x.IndexOf('x'), 1);
This will remove the first occurance of 'x' in the string. If there could be more than one occurance, and you want to remove all, using Replace is more efficient:
var x = "tesx".Replace("x", String.Empty);

Remove takes an int parameter for the index within the string to start removing characters, see msdn. The remove call must automatically convert the char to its ASCII integer index and try to remove the character at that index from the string, it is not trying to remove the character itself.
If you just want to remove any cases where x occurs in the string do:
"testx".Replace("x",string.Empty);
If you want to remove the first index of x in the string do:
var value = "testx1x2";
var newValue = value.Remove(value.IndexOf('x'), 1);

Since you are passing a char in the function and this value is getting converted to int at runtime hence you are getting the runtime error because the value of char at runtime is more than the length of the string.You may try like this:-
var x = "tesx";
var s = x.Remove(x.IndexOf('x'), 1);
or
var s = x.Replace("x",string.Empty);
.Remove takes the int as parameter. Remove takes two parameters. The first one is what position in your string you want to start at. (The count starts at zero.) The second parameter is how many characters you want to delete, starting from the position you specified.
On a side note:
From MSDN:
This method(.Remove) does not modify the value of the current instance.
Instead, it returns a new string in which the number of characters
specified by the count parameter have been removed. The characters are
removed at the position specified by startIndex.

You can use extension methods to create your own methods for already existing classes. Consider following example:
using System;
using MyExtensions;
namespace ConsoleApplication
{
class Program
{
static void Main(string[] args)
{
const string str1 = "tesx";
var x = str1.RemoveByChar('x');
Console.WriteLine(x);
Console.ReadKey();
}
}
}
namespace MyExtensions
{
public static class StringExtensions
{
public static string RemoveByChar(this String str, char c)
{
return str.Remove(str.IndexOf(c), 1);
}
}
}

Related

How to reverse string in C# [duplicate]

I didn't get the problem - I was trying to do a simple action:
for(i = x.Length-1, j = 0 ; i >= 0 ; i--, j++)
{
backx[j] = x[i];
}
Both are declared:
String x;
String backx;
What is the problem ? It says the error in the title...
If there is a problem - is there another way to do that?
The result (As the name 'backx' hints) is that backx will contain the string X backwards.
P.S. x is not empty - it contains a substring from another string.
Strings are immutable: you can retrieve the character at a certain position, but you cannot change the character to a new one directly.
Instead you'll have to build a new string with the change. There are several ways to do this, but StringBuilder does the job in a similar fashion to what you already have:
StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder(backx);
sb[j] = x[i];
backx = sb.ToString();
EDIT: If you take a look at the string public facing API, you'll see this indexer:
public char this[int index] { get; }
This shows that you can "get" a value, but because no "set" is available, you cannot assign values to that indexer.
EDITx2: If you're looking for a way to reverse a string, there are a few different ways, but here's one example with an explanation as to how it works: http://www.dotnetperls.com/reverse-string
String is immutable in .NET - this is why you get the error.
You can get a reverse string with LINQ:
string x = "abcd";
string backx = new string(x.Reverse().ToArray());
Console.WriteLine(backx); // output: "dcba"
String are immuatable. You have convert to Char Array and then you would be able to modify.
Or you can use StringBuilder.
for example
char[] wordArray = word.ToCharArray();
In C# strings are immutable. You cannot "set" Xth character to whatever you want. If yo uwant to construct a new string, or be able to "edit" a string, use i.e. StringBuilder class.
Strings are immutable in C#. You can read more about it here: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/362314fe.aspx
Both the variables you have are string while you are treating them as if they were arrays (well, they are). Of course it is a valid statement to access characters from a string through this mechanism, you cannot really assign it that way.
Since you are trying to reverse a string, do take a look at this post. It has lot of information.
public static string ReverseName( string theName)
{
string revName = string.Empty;
foreach (char a in theName)
{
revName = a + revName;
}
return revName;
}
This is simple and does not involve arrays directly.
The code below simply swaps the index of each char in the string which enables you to only have to iterate half way through the original string which is pretty efficient if you're dealing with a lot of characters. The result is the original string reversed. I tested this with a string consisting of 100 characters and it executed in 0.0000021 seconds.
private string ReverseString(string testString)
{
int j = testString.Length - 1;
char[] charArray = new char[testString.Length];
for (int i = 0; i <= j; i++)
{
if (i != j)
{
charArray[i] = testString[j];
charArray[j] = testString[i];
}
j--;
}
return new string(charArray);
}
In case you need to replace e.g. index 2 in string use this (it is ugly, but working and is easily maintainbable)
V1 - you know what you want to put their. Here you saying in pseudocode string[2] = 'R';
row3String.Replace(row3String[2], 'R');
V2 - you need to put their char R or char Y. Here string[2] = 'R' if was 'Y' or if was not stay 'Y' (this one line if needs some form of else)
row3String.Replace(row3String[2], row3String[2].Equals('Y') ? 'R' : 'Y');

convert string to int error in c#

Hello I am trying to convert String to Integer.
The code below shows a part from where I am trying to convert my string to integer.
if (other.gameObject.CompareTag("PickUp"))
{
if ( checkpointboolean == false)
{
string pickupName = other.ToString(); //other = Pickup4
//Remove first 6 letters thus remaining with '4'
string y = pickupName.Substring(6);
print(y); // 4 is being printed
int x = 0;
int.TryParse(y, out x);
print (x); // 0 is being printed
I also tried the below code and instead of '0' I am getting the following error:
if (other.gameObject.CompareTag("PickUp"))
{
if ( checkpointboolean == false)
{
//Get Object name ex: Pickup4
string pickupName = other.ToString();
//Remove first 6 letters thus remaining with '4'
string y = pickupName.Substring(6);
print(y);
int x = int.Parse(y);
FormatException: Input string was not in the correct format
System.Int32.Parse (System.String s)
int.TryParse returns a boolean, true if it succeeded and false if not. You need to wrap this in a if block and do something with that logic.
if(int.TryParse(y, out x))
print (x); // y was able to be converted to an int
else
// inform the caller that y was not numeric, your conversion to number failed
As far as why your number is not converted I could not say until you post what the string value is.
Your first attempt is the best for this case, that code works fine, The int.TryParse() giving 0 to the out parameter and returns false means the conversion is failed. The input string is not in the correct format/ it cannot be converted to an integer. You can check this by using the return value of the int.TryParse(). For this what you need to do is :-
if(int.TryParse(y, out x))
print (x); //
else
print ("Invalid input - Conversion failed");
First of all, ToString() usually uses for debug purpose so there's no guarantee that
other.ToString()
will return the expected "Pickup4" in the next version of the software. You, probably, want something like
int x = other.gameObject.SomeProperty;
int x = other.SomeOtherProperty;
int x = other.ComputePickUp();
...
If you, however, insist on .ToString() you'd rather not hardcode six letters (the reason is the same: debug information tends to change from version to version), but use regular expressions or something:
var match = Regex.Match(other.ToString(), "-?[0-9]+");
if (match.Success) {
int value;
if (int.TryParse(match.Value, out value))
print(value);
else
print(match.Value + " is not an integer value");
}
else
print("Unexpected value: " + other.ToString());

Index of the string can be long?

I want to know whether we can give the index of the string as Long data type.
var i=long.Parse(Console.ReadLine());
var result = testString[i-1];
the second line giving me the error by saying that "The best overloaded method match for 'string.this[int]' has some invalid arguments."
No you can't use long for most collection types (you haven't specified what testString is).
One way to get around this would be to segregate the string into a multi-part / multi-dimension array then use a multiplier to get which part of the array to check.
For example:
Your index is 100,000 and you have an array of shorts (32,767 length)...
string[,] testString = new string[100, 32766]; //Replace this with your Initialisation / existing string
var arrayRank = (int)Math.Round((double) 100000 / 32767, 0);
var arrayIndex = (int)Math.Round((double)100000 % 32767, 0);
//Test this works.
//testString[arrayRank, arrayIndex] = "test"; - Test to see that the array range is assignable.
var result = testString[arrayRank, arrayIndex]; //Test value is what we expect
This may not be the most efficient way to go about things, but it is a workaround.
No, it cannot accept a long. The only overload accepts an int indexer. You would need to change your code to int.Parse() instead of long.Parse()
There is no way to pass long as an index of array, compiler doesn't allow that.
Workaround can be converting the long to int, this is called narrow conversion.
var result= testString[(int)i)];

Convert.ToInt32 user input array to int c#

I have the attached code which trys to find all 1s in an array input by the user.
The program asks the user to select the array size, then input a number of that size with some 1s in it. It then counts the number of 1s found.
I guess that the input the user gives is in the form of a string? So, if they input 12345 it would be a string with one 1 in it.
I am trying to convert the array to int32, though I don't think I fully understand why it has to be int32 either.
If somebody could help me understand this programs' workings and why I'm getting the following error I'd be thankful.
An unhandled exception of type 'System.FormatException' occurred in
mscorlib.dll Additional information: Input string was not in a correct
format.
using System;
using System.Collections.Generic;
using System.Linq;
using System.Text;
using System.Threading.Tasks;
namespace count1s
{
class Program
{
static void Main(string[] args)
{
int count = 0;
Console.WriteLine("Enter a number for the array length");
int limit = int.Parse(Console.ReadLine());
int[] array1s = new int[limit];
Console.WriteLine("Enter a number with some 1s in it");
for(int i=0; i<limit; i++)
{
array1s[i] = Convert.ToInt32(Console.ReadLine());
}
foreach (int number in array1s)
{
if (number == 1)
{
count++;
}
}
Console.WriteLine("The number of 1s in the array is: {0}", count);
Console.ReadLine();
}
}
}
You are getting this error because you are entering the array elements in one line.
If you enter one element on one line then program will work fine.
If you want to accept numbers on one line then you can use split function like
String []numbers = Console.ReadLine().Split(' ');
for (int i = 0; i < limit; i++)
{
array1s[i] = Convert.ToInt32(numbers[i]);
}
foreach (int number in array1s)
{
if (number == 1)
{
count++;
}
}
I don't think I fully understand why it has to be int32 either.
It doesn't have to be. That depends on your input. If the user enters a number small enough, it can also fit into a short (which is 16 bits), and you can parse the string into that.
why I'm getting the following error
Because you're trying to parse a string which isn't parse-able to a valid int value. If you're not sure the input is valid, you can use a method such as int.TryParse, which returns a boolean indicating the success or failure of the parsing:
int i = 0;
while (i < limit)
{
string value = Console.ReadLine();
int parsedValue;
if (!int.TryParse(value, out parsedValue))
{
Console.WriteLine("You've entered an invalid number. Please try again");
continue;
}
array[i] = parsedValue;
i++;
}
If you want to count all occurrences of 1, you can simply use Enumerable.Count which takes a predicate:
return array.Count(number => number == 1);
Use this as
for(int i=0; i<limit; i++)
{
int value;
var isNumber = int.TryParse(Console.ReadLine(), out value);
if(isNumber)
{
array1s[i] = value;
}
else
{
Console.WriteLine("Invalid value you have entered");
continue;
}
}
Well, now I feel like a bit of an idiot.
I tried some of your responses, thanks very much for that, and they are good. I went back and tried the code I originally posted as well and found that it does work. I just need to hit carriage return after each entry into the array.
I'll take a look at all of this properly later to find out what is going on.
Thanks again all - gotta say - was really surprised to get so many responses on here so quickly. Awesome!!
I just found a really good article on the Microsoft: DEV204x Programming with C# course I have started online. I think this will be helpful to all who follow with the same questions I had. Hopefully I'm not breaking any copyright laws or stackoverflow rules. It's a free course, so I doubt it.
Data Conversions
C# supports two inherent types of conversion (casting) for data types, implicit and explicit. C# will use implicit conversion where it can, mostly in the case when a conversion will not result in a loss of data or when the conversion is possible with a compatible data type. The following is an example of an implicit data conversion.
Converting from smaller to larger integral types:
int myInt = 2147483647;
long myLong= myInt;
The long type has a 64-bit size in memory while the int type uses 32-bits. Therefore, the long can easily accomodate any value stored in the int type. Going from a long to an int may result in data loss however and you should use explicit casting for that.
Explicit casts are accomplished in one of two ways as demonstrated with the following coe sample.
double myDouble = 1234.6;
int myInt;
// Cast double to int by placing the type modifier ahead of the type to be converted
// in parentheses
myInt = (int)myDouble;
The second option is to use the methods provided in the .NET Framework.
double myDouble = 1234.6;
int myInt;
// Cast double to int by using the Convert class and the ToInt32() method.
// This converts the double value to a 32-bit signed integer
myInt = Convert.ToInt32(myDouble);
You will find many other methods in the Convert class that cast to different integral data types such as ToBoolean(), ToByte(), ToChar(), etc.
The Convert.ToInt32() method can also be used to cast a string literal to a numeric data type. For example, you may have GUI-based application in which uses input data into text boxes. These values are string values when passed to the code in your application. Use of the above method to cast the string to numbers can help prevent exceptions in your code when trying to use the wrong data type in a specific area.
C# also provides another mechanism to deal with casting types. The use of the TryParse() method and Parse() methods can help with casting as well. These methods are attached to the types in C# rather than the Convert class. An example will help demonstrate.
// TryParse() example
bool result = Int32.TryParse(value, out number);
// Parse() example
int number = Int32.Parse(value);
In the TryParse() example, the method returns a Boolean result indicating if the conversion succeeded. In the Parse() example, if the conversion does not succeed, an exception will be thrown.

substring help in c#

I have string qty__c which may or may not have a decimal point
The code below gives me a System.ArgumentOutOfRangeException: Length cannot be less than zero.
qty__c = qty__c.Substring(0, qty__c.IndexOf("."));
How do i cater to if there is no "."?
Thanks
The simplest way is just to test it separately:
int dotIndex = quantity.IndexOf('.');
if (dotIndex != -1)
{
quantity = quantity.Substring(0, dotIndex);
}
There are alternatives though... for example if you really wanted to do it in a single statement, you could either use a conditional operator above, or:
quantity = quantity.Split('.')[0];
or slightly more efficiently:
// C# 4 version
quantity = quantity.Split(new[] {'.'}, 2)[0];
// Pre-C# 4 version
quantity = quantity.Split(new char[] {'.'}, 2)[0];
(The second form effectively stops splitting after finding the first dot.)
Another option would be to use regular expressions.
On the whole, I think the first approach is the most sensible though. If you find you need to do this often, consider writing a method to encapsulate it:
// TODO: Think of a better name :)
public static string SubstringBeforeFirst(string text, string delimiter)
{
int index = text.IndexOf(delimiter);
return index == -1 ? text : text.Substring(0, index);
}
You just have to test if qty__c have a point in it before calling Substring :
var pointPos = qty__c.IndexOf('.');
if (pointPos != -1)
{
qty__c = qty__c.Substring(0, pointPos);
}
Use IndexOf method on that string. If returned value is -1, there is no character that was searched.
int index = mystring.IndexOf('.');
In your code, you are not checking the returned value of IndexOf. In the case where '.' is not present in the string, an exception will be thrown because SubString has been passed -1 as second parameter.
var indexofstring=quantity.Indexof('.');
if(indexofstring!=-1)
{
quantity=quantity.SubString(0,indexofstring);
}
Assuming you are looking for the decimal point in a number, which is at offset 3 both in
'123.456' and '123', then one solution is
var index = (mystring & ".").IndexOf(".")
(Sorry about the VB, I'm not sure of C# syntax)

Categories