I'm just finishing authorization and resource server for OAuth2, using DotNetOpenAuth 4.3.4. For testing, I created test client by implementing OAuth2Client.
Because I'm using DNOA for all the communication and request parsing, I'm not sure if I fully understand what is going on under the hood. But this knowledge is very important when I make documentation.
So, could you please explain to me, how client authentification works in DNOA? I use authorization code as grant_type and when I use my test client to exchange code for access_token, the DNOA somehow validate the client_secret and client_id. I downloaded source code for DNOA, but it not helped.
When I set breakpoint to Oauth2 controller(token method) and parse the request as HttpRequestMessage, i see the request contains "grant_type", "code" and "redirect_uri". But where are client_id and client_secret?
Also, can you tell me where I can find any usable documentation for DNOA? I need to create documentation, which will be valid and usable for all platforms, not just C#, which can use DNOA.
Related question:
I somewhere read, that we should not create authorization codes for unauthentificated clients, but this is exactly what DNOA does (since I receive authorization code even if secret is wrong). Is it ok?
Edit:
This is the request I'm trying to read. It is token request made by DNOA client. I can not see the client_id and client_secret under other parameters like "code", "redirect_uri" and "grant_type". I tought they have to be together. Maybe I'm missing something important from http requests and responses.
When I let DNOA to HandleTokenRequest(request) to continue, it is successfully authenticate the client application (fails when bad secret is set in DNOA client app config).
Edit 2
private readonly WebServerClient Client;
protected override string QueryAccessToken(Uri returnUrl, string authorizationCode)
{
var authorization = Client.ProcessUserAuthorization();
if (authorization != null)
return authorization.AccessToken;
else
return null;
}
This is my implementation of QueryAccessToken. It is from some sample. I think I created this at the beginning and did not change it, because it worked.
Going rought DNOA source I found out it is method from OAuth 1. THis can be the problem. But the question is, why it works ok with right client cerdentials and not working with bad ones.
Final edit
Looks like DNOA client uses http Basic authorization (client_id and secret are in header). But I need the DNOA server to be able to grab these parameters from POST.
If anyone know how to set DNOA to support client_id and client_secret in POST parameters, it would be awesome!
Thank you
The authorization code grant requires two steps.
The first step is the browser redirecting to the identity provider and displaying the logon ui. The authorization code is returned to the browser by the identity provider and then, from the browser to the client application. This step doesn't involve client secret! This is because the end user can debug this part of the flow and she should not learn the value of the client secret.
Then, when the client application has the onetime authorization code, it concacts the token endpoint directly (server-to-server) to exchange the authorization code for authorization token. This is where client id and client secret are used to verify that only legitimate client applications exchange codes for tokens.
The idea behind this flow is to protect the end user from exposing her password to the client application and also protect the client application from exposing its client secret to the end user.
Also note that the authorization code grant flow is the most complicated one as it involves both username/password (provided by the end user) and clientid/client secret (provided by the client application). There are other flows which allow to get the authorization token in slightly different way, namely:
resource owner grant which involves sending username/password directly by end user to the token endpoint of the identity provider. This flow is suited for desktop/mobile/native apps where the logon ui can be customized (but it also can raise suspicions and users could proably refuse to use it)
client credentials flow which involves sending clientid/client secret by the client application to the idntity provider. There is no end user but only the client application authenticating in the identity provider.
More on flows here:
http://aaronparecki.com/articles/2012/07/29/1/oauth2-simplified
As for DNOA, I found it clean and understandable but the docs are lacking. Fortunately, examples are great and although barely documented, you can find almost everything there. Nonetheless, I was able to set up oauth2 identity provider and resource server in three days and support all four oauth2 flows. I am not going to dig deeply into details as this is not what your question is about, however, if you have DNOA specific questions, just ask.
Edit:: regarding your QueryAccessToken implementation, it seems that you are using the WebServerClient internally. In my code I just initialize its properties:
WebServerClient client = ...
client.ClientIdentifier = "client_id";
client.ClientCredentialApplicator =
ClientCredentialApplicator.PostParameter( "client_secret" );
With these two configured, both client_id and client_secret are sent to the token service with the client_secret passed in POST params.
Related
I have a ASP.NET MVC (NOT ASP.NET Core) single page application with angular js on the front end.
My client (browser) talks to server through ASP.NET Web APIs. Now, the web application is on https but anonymous. There is no login/ user authentication.
The web app is in the form of a wizard where user can go back and forth and add or update input fields on the web page. The form input values are then updated on the server through Web API.
I'm looking for a way to secure my Web API calls alone, especially the POST/ PUT requests. In summary, I want to prevent any user calling my Web API directly from POSTMAN or Fiddler. The Web API, though anonymous can be only called from the browser session where the request originated.
What are options do I have to achieve this?
Can I use Anti-Forgery token here (without authentication)?
One way, I can think of achieving this is to add a custom header to each request and store some kind of session key in the header. Then, validate the custom header on every request I received from client. Are any other ways of achieving this out-of-box or some proven library without going for custom solution?
If I have to go for the above custom solution, what are the pitfalls or potential issues I need to be aware of?
First of all when you remove login and there's no authentication mechanism in your application, there's really no way to secure anything, because anyone can access your APIs. I think what you want is to make sure that your APIs are called only from your own website. Unfortunately you can't completely achieve that, since your web APIs are http/https, and anyone, from anywhere (like postman, fiddler, ...) can create a http request and call your API.
All you can do is to make it harder for your API to response to requests, like using Anti-Forgery as you mentioned.
And also I suggest you add a cookie for your application and check that cookie in every request, in this case it's more complicated ( not impossible ) to call your API using Fiddler or Postman.
And last I suggest that you use CORS, so browsers would only allow your domain to call your APIs. So nobody can call your APIs in a browser from different domain.
Based on answer from #Arvin and comment from #Evk, here's how I plan to proceed:
Once, the user starts the anonymous session generate a GUID using regular Guid.NewGuid() method and save it in DB to identify the request (I'm doing this now). However, as mentioned here,
GUID can be unique but they are not cryptographically secured.
Hence, instead of using plain-text GUID, encrypt it with current timestamp as token and append it with request query string.
For every subsequent API request, read the token from query string, decrypt it and validate it as follows:
Check the timestamp. If the time difference is more than pre-defined time (i.e. token expired), reject the request
Validate the unique id (GUID) against DB
Since, I'm not using plain text GUID anymore, the URI would not easy to guess.
Additionally, with the timestamp, URI is invalidated after sometime. While theoretically it is still possible to call the API through Fiddler but this should make it very difficult for the attacker, if not impossible.
As a further security measure, I can also add Anti-Forgery token to the request
As per my understanding this helps solving my underlying problem and with this approach, I may not even need add a cookie to secure my anonymous session.
Love to hear from you all if this approach looks good and how can it be improved.
I also once had the weird need for having session functionality on WebAPI and created an OWIN Session middleware that does exactly what you're aiming for.
The library is called OwinSessionMiddleware and is available on github and NuGet.
Usage
public class Startup
{
public void Configuration(IAppBuilder app)
{
app.UseSessionMiddleware();
// other middleware registrations...
app.UseWebApi();
}
}
You can also pass some options to further tweak cookie-name, add a database backed session store (instead of in-memory), add your own session id generator (instead of default id generator which is based on GUID + secure random part generated by RNGCryptoServiceProvider).
The unique session id itself is stored as a secure cookie and the session is restored automatically by the middleware on each request.
There are extension methods you can call inside your API controller to get and set session data:
public SomeApiController : ApiController
{
public IHttpActionResult MyAction()
{
var requestCount = Request.GetSessionProperty<int>("RequestCount");
Request.SetSessionProperty("RequestCount", ++requestCount);
}
}
Create Anonymous JWT token with some claims related to your scenario, Sign it with some key, Use that as in cookie (Http Only) or As bearer token. To make it little more harder further combine it with some cookies.
1)verify token signature and
2) Verify token expiry time
3) Verify Claim(skey) against cookies(skey)- no database storage required everything is in ur JWT token.
I am using Identity Server4 for a proof of concept project.I have implemented the identity server and I can receive an access token when I authenticate successfully.
For authentication I use, the following endpoint:
http://identity-vm-01/connect/token
and the details I post are:
Now, I would like to check if the token that I receive is valid. For that I am using the following endpoint.
http://identity-vm-01/connect/introspect
with a basic auth header using the client_id and client_secret as shown above, and pass token in the body.
But I receive an Unauthorized error. 401 . It will be great if someone could tell me what is that I am doing wrong.
Thank you
You need to define a scope secret for api1 (on the Scope class) and use the scope name and secret as client_id/secret.
Clients for the introspection endpoint are not really clients in the OAuth 2 sense - they are APIs.
I'm trying to create something like: Client authenticates and gets token from custom STS1, next client authorizes with machine key and is issued token on custom STS2 and gets another token. With last token, client requests methods on RP service.
All services are hosted on IIS and are using active federation scenario.
Both STS's have endpoints with ws2007Federation and ws2007Http bindings, and RP use ws2007FederationBinding with STS2 as an issuer.
If I create channel with CreateChannelWithIssuedToken I can see only token from STS1 and can't get token from STS2.
So I decided to pass token from STS1 as ActAs RST's property on request to STS2 token. And that failed - cannot decrypt token.
How can I pass both tokens to STS2 and merge up claims in them?
Is it a bad idea - to send with RST just extracted claims from STS1 token?
Generally you will only want to utilize one token at each step. So if you need to merge up claims, you will want to do that at the claims transformation step of the second STS.
So the flow would be authenticate with STS1, then authenticate with STS2 with the token from STS1. At that point you would pass through the claims and transform to add additional claims as needed. Then the resulting Token would be ready to consume from the RP application.
I have actually started a blog series about a really similar scenario that we recently architected. Not to be overly self promoting, but it doesn't make me any money, so I'll post it in case it is helpful.
http://www.livingthearchitecture.com/mixing-sso-with-existing-technologies/
I would be glad to go more in depth, but depending on the specifics of your scenario, the specifics of the solution will change greatly. I think the above expresses the general approach you will want. Let me know if I can help any more.
I am trying to get access to OneDrive for Business using OAuth2.0 authentication protocol. I have followed this example:
http://msdn.microsoft.com/EN-US/library/dn605894(v=office.15).aspx
an this is my code so far:
// Create an authentication context
AuthenticationContext ac = new AuthenticationContext(string.Format("https://login.windows.net/{0}",
ClaimsPrincipal.Current.FindFirst(TenantIdClaimType).Value));
String id = ClaimsPrincipal.Current.FindFirst(TenantIdClaimType).Value;
// Create a client credential based on the application id and secret.
ClientCredential clcred = new ClientCredential(AppPrincipalId, AppKey);
// Using the authorization code acquire an access token.
var arAD = ac.AcquireTokenByAuthorizationCode(code, new Uri(appRedirect), clcred);
I am getting a Authorization code is malformed error. I don't understand why I am getting this message.
Any help would be appreciated!
Had the same issue when I was trying to get authorization code manually and then use it from console application. Not sure why it doesn't work for me.
But when I use it from Web App, the same app which performed authorization and received code in return (because I specified it as returnURL) - everything works.
I suggest you to have a look on this example
https://github.com/AzureADSamples/WebApp-WebAPI-OAuth2-UserIdentity-DotNet
And also this article to understand what's happening under the good:
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/exchangedev/archive/2014/03/25/using-oauth2-to-access-calendar-contact-and-mail-api-in-exchange-online-in-office-365.aspx
P.S.
It's not a OneDrive, but I had exactly the same problem, so if you can make it working with Exchange or GraphApi, then it should work for OneDrive as well.
Authorization code is malformed error is occured if you send the auth code in incorrect format. May be the authorization code which you are sending is encoded value of authcode and session state. you need to seperate both values and send the auth code only. or decode the '&' symbol(seperator) between auth code and session state and send them as two parameters.
The method AcquireTokenByAuthorizationCode(...) from ADAL4j takes only authcode.
I'm trying to create web page that access the (business) private calendar of the company and insert events if the time slot is available. Still I'm facing an authentication problem.
The API manual states that I should use an API key and Oauth2LeggedAuthenticator, so I did all this and the request that is fired is quite okey (it has a oauth token and such) But still the response is an exception with Invalid Credentials; Easy to say is that my credentials are wrong, still clientID, clientSecret and API Key are valid; I doubt the 2 last params of the 2legged authenticater, is this correct?
var provider = new NativeApplicationClient(GoogleAuthenticationServer.Description);
provider.ClientIdentifier = ClientCredentials.ClientID;
provider.ClientSecret = ClientCredentials.ClientSecret;
var authenticator =
new OAuth2LeggedAuthenticator(ClientCredentials.ClientID, ClientCredentials.ClientSecret, "myworkusername", "workdomain.com");
Google.Apis.Calendar.v3.CalendarService service = new Google.Apis.Calendar.v3.CalendarService(authenticator);
service.Key = ClientCredentials.ApiKey;
var result = service.CalendarList.List().Fetch();
Assert.IsTrue(result.Items.Count > 0);
NB: At the time of writing you can only used 2-legged authentication with Google Apps for Business/Eduction, this won't work on personal accounts as there's no way to get an OAuth 1.0 key/secret pair, you will have to use online authentication at least once (but you can use the out-of-browser option so you don't have to create a dedicated page).
Your code is correct apart from you don't need the first three lines relating to the NativeApplicationClient. This is most likely failing because you haven't properly set the OAuth keys, this causes 401s.
The other thing that causes 401s is using "matt#example.com" instead of "matt" as the username, the username is without including your domain.
To setup OAuth follow the instructions in this article from Google.
The most important parts to note are "Allow access to all APIs" must be unchecked and you have to individually grant access to all the APIs. If this hasn't been done you will get a 401 Invalid Credentials error. You then also need to turn those services on in the api console. If the api console step hasn't been done you will get a different error of 403 Daily Limit Exceeded.
This will cause you problems if you were previously relying on the "Allow access to all APIs" to use various services, you will have to grant them all individually as far as I understand it to use the v3 APIs. This seems to have been confirmed by google (4th reply by Nicolas Garnier) and is supposedly a bug, but that is an old post so it looks as if it's here to stay.
For reference once this has been done, this code will work, which in essence is the same as yours:
var auth = new OAuth2LeggedAuthenticator(domainName, consumerSecret, usernameWithoutDomain, domainName); //domainName is presently used as the OAuth ConsumerKey for Google's 2legged OAuth
var service = new CalendarService(auth);
service.Key = serviceKey;
var results = service.CalendarList.List().Fetch();
Console.WriteLine(results.Items.Count);
So in summary:
In Google Apps "Manage this Domain" > "Advanced Tools"
Using "Manage OAuth domain key" enable key, generate secret, uncheck "Allow access to all APIs".
Using "Manage third party OAuth Client access" enable the APIs you want access to using your domain as "Client Name" and the APIs you want to access e.g. "http://www.google.com/calendar/feeds/" for the calendar.
Then finally create a project in the API console, use the APIKey as the serviceKey in the above example and turn on the APIs you need to access.
I am answering this as I kept hitting this question when I was trying to find out why my code was constantly returning 401s. Hope this helps someone as the Google instructions are awful and scattered all over the place at the moment.