I'm not sure how to explain this but occasionally I will experience an issue where I popup a dialog (say a file browser), and after it is closed, part of the dialog remains visible on top of my app. Sometimes if I minimize and restore it will go away.
Is this a common issue?
I have only ever seen this where the window that you are over stops responding and cannot update the area which has been revealed. However as soon as it does respond again then it redraws.
Maybe you could repeat this test and not minimize the window behind?
Related
I'm just starting out with MonoMac in Xamarin Studio, and I've run into the strangest problem:
I a window with an NSButton and a NSTextField on it. By this point I've cut out the event handler on the button, so it doesn't DO anything, except highlight when I click it. The button creation code looks like this:
nsButton = new NSButton(new System.Drawing.RectangleF(0, 0, 100, 100));
nsButton.BezelStyle = NSBezelStyle.RoundRect;
nsButton.Font = NSFont.SystemFontOfSize(
NSFont.SystemFontSizeForControlSize(NSControlSize.Regular));
nsButton.StringValue = text;
...and then it gets added to the window like so:
nsView.AddSubview(control.Handle as NSView);
(because in this part of the code, control.Handle is typed as object, and nsView is the main view on the window).
All runs and works fine at first. But, if I click repeatedly on that button, eventually the window just closes. No error, no exception, and the app itself doesn't quit; menus continue to respond and cheerfully log messages when I use them. But the window is simply -- gone.
It's extremely repeatable: it happens after 21 clicks. If I add an event handler that updates the NSTextField (e.g. hello.Caption="Foo";), then it happens after 19 clicks. It doesn't matter whether I click fast or slow; it's always the same number of clicks. Note that there is no code in the project to close the window, and the window doesn't even have a close box; I know of no legitimate way to close it short of quitting the app.
I am baffled here, and don't know how to debug this further. Does Xamarin have some sort of evaluation limit that closes your windows after so-many events? Is it a framework bug? Any insight will be greatly appreciated.
But, if I click repeatedly on that button, eventually the window just
closes. No error, no exception, and the app itself doesn't quit; menus
continue to respond and cheerfully log messages when I use them. But
the window is simply -- gone.
This "disappearing without a trace" sometimes occurs when an application crashes in native code badly enough. This can occur due to bugs in the binding code or mistakes made in calling the native APIs that corrupt internal cocoa state. I believe you are using MonoMac, and that this particular issue has been fixed in Xamarin.Mac.
You can sometimes get more information from the output window or by attaching lldb to your process.
This turned out to be the same issue as this one, in a slightly different guise.
In short, I wasn't keeping a reference to the NSWindow object, but instead was letting it go out of scope. So the GUI window would stick around for a while, but eventually (after some number of events or other code creating behind-the-scenes garbage) it is noticed and disposed of by the garbage collector. The window is then torn down.
It's all perfectly reasonable once you think of it, and happens under both Xamarin and MonoMac (just at slightly different times).
The simple solution, of course, is to retain a reference to the window until you're truly done with it. Problem solved!
(And yes, I feel a bit sheepish, but hopefully this question will get found by future Mac C# developers, and save them some grief.)
I'm working on a rather big project with my team and after a while, we struck into a big problem.
Infact when we minimize the main window of the application, clicking on the taskbar to restore it results in a "bing" sound (the one that windows uses when you are trying to interact with a background window when a modal dialog is opened on it). I can't restore the window except if I press ENTER button (after obviusly clicking on it).
We are using XNA to render something inside a WindowsFormsHost component in our WPF application and the problem comes out when we change something that is not connected directly with wpf (something inside the rendering engine, so it works only with XNA).
I can't post any code because I don't own any rights of it and would be meaningless because the project is enough big.
So my question is: what are the things that can produce a problem like this one (unable to restore window sound) when you click on the taskbar?
At least I can understand where to search for this bug, because I don't even understand where I shall dirt my hands in.
Important notes: I'm using a splash screen and the problems come up when I do something on a second window (so not directly the main one) which is not modal
Thanks for any suggestion
We solved the problem by finding out that there is a bug with an external component that we used inside our application. Still I don't understand how this bug has been created, if someone has a better answer I'll mark it.
Occasionally, seemingly randomly, when I close a dialog form my main form seems to move back in the window order, disappearing behind the next application back (usually Visual Studio). It retains focus, so clicking it in the taskbar minimises it, requiring another click. Whenever this happens, the control colours seem to change a little as well, but revert if I maximise and restore the window.
Any idea why this happens?
Edit: This happens when I'm debugging; it might happen at runtime too, but I usually don't have anything behind the application then, so I haven't noticed. Nobody has mentioned it.
This will happen when the dialog closes and Windows cannot find any window in your app that isn't disabled. Forced to move the focus somewhere, it will pick a window of another app to give the focus to. Your form will disappear behind it.
Exactly why your main form is disabled when this happens isn't clear. The color change certainly suggests you are changing the Enabled property of the form. Everything turns battle-ship gray when you do that. Setting Enabled back to true after the dialog closes doesn't work, it's too late. Just don't tinker with Enabled, the ShowDialog() method already disables other windows.
I have this Windows Forms application where it sits in the notification area. Clicking on the icon brings it up front, clicking it again (or clicking on the app X icon) sends it back. This is the type of app that having the window always on top is important when it's displayed by clicking the icon (it's optional though).
Right-clicking the icon brings up a context menu where one can select to enable the "always on top" option or not. When the application first starts up, the app settings are read from an XML file and I'm 99% that this is working as it should, the TopMost property is properly read (and written).
After some time (minutes, hours, days, whatever; I normally hibernate and rarely shutdown) the TopMost stops working. I don't change the option, I don't think anything is changing the option value but I click the notification area icon and app is not brought up front. It shows up but it's on the background (it displays on Alt+Tab), it's not "always on top" as it should. I bring up the context menu, disable the option (cause it's enabled) and enable it back and it starts to work after that. The app is now "always on top". However, it can lose this ability anytime after a while.
I can't understand why this happens and how this happens. Does anyone have any idea why? If not, any idea how could I try to debug such behavior?
EDIT:
I added a piece of code to show a MessageBox when the TopMost property was changed to see if I could notice any strange behavior but it was no good. It didn't help because the form was with TopMost = true but it still was in the background...
There is more than just one "Topmost" window. Topmost just says "Before all non-topmost windows".
I am pretty sure a reinitialization of the desktop (such as when hibernating) requires another SetWindowPos(hwnd, HWND_TOPMOST, ...) (which is the underlying Win32 API call).
As a workaround, you could reset and set the property again when showing the window.
Another possibility is that hiding the window also changes the Z order - either implicitely how Win32 implements that, or explicitely in the way WinForms call the hide/show window.
Like peterchen i also don't have a clue how to get the root cause. But why not make it a little bit simpler?
When you click on your Icon you'll show up your window and rely that TopMost is still active. Why not call SetWindowPos() with the current setting right before you show the window. This shouldn't make any performance problems (only happens if the user clicks the icon) nor any other side effect.
I know, it would be great to find out the root cause, but maybe it's not worth if you can solve it with such a little workaround.
I want to create an alarm app for myself. On certain conditions (i need to poll websites) i want my app to inform me and make it HARD TO MISS. So i can take appropriate action or ignore it if i need to do something else.
I wrote a test app and using a BalloonTip (ShowBalloonTip with notifyIcon) isnt great. One of my previous apps brings the window in front of you and does a MessageBox however that doesnt always work or work well (if i somehow miss it or accidentally forget to click ok no futher messages will occur).
What are your suggestions?
You could also make it a system tray application and change the icon out if there is something which requires attention, a la a messenger application. That may not be "hard to miss" but I am trained (for better or worse) to look down at the icon tray when I see something blinking.
Where I work, we have a TimeTracker application (built in house) with which developers are supposed to log what we worked on and when. I am notorious for not using it. So, I wrote my own (Windows Forms) version for my own use which, every hour opens up and takes over my screen:
It is a frameless dialog which consumes the entire screen.
TopMost = True.
On resize, it sets WindowsState = Normal and resizes to fill the screen.
While it is open, it polls for taskmgr.exe and procexp.exe and kills them if found.
It disables the start menu to prevent cmd.exe commands from the menu in Windows 7.
The only way to close it is to enter a log, only then is the OK button shown!
So far, it's working out well - no one has been able to break it!
My less drastic suggestion would be to have a notification which pops up momentarily above the system tray. After a second or two, fade it out. Keep showing the notification every 30 seconds or so until it is dismissed.
Always-on-top window in the corner of the screen?
You could always set your window to be a top most window, make it full screen, and activate it. It would be very, very hard to miss...
Granted, it would also be very annoying, and not something I'd do to other users...
My "real" suggestion would be to use sound along with standard notification methods if this is going to be used by other people, as that's an easy way to grab attention without necessarily killing their workflow. A modeless window that appears in a corner of the screen, especially if combined with sound and color, can be very effective to grab attention.
The industry has been adopting these ambient orb devices and variations of it when such a hard-to-miss notification is required. It is used for tracking the stock-market and for broken-daily-builds.
http://www.ambientdevices.com/cat/orb/MAN_Ambient%20Orb_3-23-03.pdf
Regards