We Keep Coding

Race condition with async/await, how to resolve

I have a problem with async/await in C#, i need it to get some object called Trades, after i get it, it needs to SAVE it. Problem is, with async/await, it is doing the SAVE first, and then go and get my trade objects. How do i ensure i get the objects first, and then does the saving.... here is my code...
private async void OnRefresh()
{
try
{
var trades = await ExchangeServiceInstance.GetTrades("");
mmTrades = new ObservableCollection<EEtrade>(trades);
tradeListView.ItemsSource = mmTrades;
}
catch { }
}
public async void OnSignalReceived()
{
// THIS NEEDS TO FINISH FIRST, BUT IT DOESN'T
await tradeListView.Dispatcher.InvokeAsync((Action)async delegate
{
if (ExchangeServiceInstance.SelectedTabIndex == CURRENT_TAB_INDEX_ITEM)
{
await Task.Delay(MMConfig.DELAYMILLISEC);
OnRefresh();
}
});
// SOMEHOW THIS GETS CALLED FIRST BEFORE THE ABOVE GETS TO FINISH!
await OnSaveTrades();
}
public async Task<int> OnSaveTrades()
{
foreach (var trade in mmTrades)
{
await ExchangeServiceInstance.OnInsertDoneTrade(trade);
}
return mmTrades.Count;
}
Any ideas guys? Thanks!

The problem is your OnRefresh method. Because the return type is void the method is not awaited [Check out this answer]. In addition you dont even try to await for the method inside your delegate
Changing the method to the following:
private async Task OnRefresh()
{
try
{
var trades = await ExchangeServiceInstance.GetTrades("");
mmTrades = new ObservableCollection<EEtrade>(trades);
tradeListView.ItemsSource = mmTrades;
}
catch { }
}
And await this method inside your delegate, should solve your problem:
public async void OnSignalReceived()
{
// THIS NEEDS TO FINISH FIRST, BUT IT DOESN'T
await tradeListView.Dispatcher.InvokeAsync((Action)async delegate
{
if (ExchangeServiceInstance.SelectedTabIndex == CURRENT_TAB_INDEX_ITEM)
{
await Task.Delay(MMConfig.DELAYMILLISEC);
await OnRefresh();
}
});
// SOMEHOW THIS GETS CALLED FIRST BEFORE THE ABOVE GETS TO FINISH!
await OnSaveTrades();
}

The use of (Action)async is basically the same as async void, and async void is almost always a mistake. Specifically, the consumer cannot know the outcome (unless it faults synchronously). The dispatcher here isn't really thinking of async.
If we assume that you must use the dispatcher here, perhaps a workaround might be to use something like a SemaphoreSlim (or maybe a TaskCompletionSource<something>) that you signal at the end of your async work (even in the exception case), and then await that; untested, but:
var tcs = new TaskCompletionSource<bool>();
await tradeListView.Dispatcher.InvokeAsync((Action)async delegate
{
try {
if (ExchangeServiceInstance.SelectedTabIndex == CURRENT_TAB_INDEX_ITEM)
{
await Task.Delay(MMConfig.DELAYMILLISEC);
OnRefresh();
}
tcs.TrySetResult(true);
} catch (Exception ex) {
tcs.TrySetException(ex);
}
});
await tcs.Task; // ensure the async work is complete
await OnSaveTrades();

First of all, you are using the async void pattern a lot. This is really bad practice for a number of reasons. You should stop doing that.
The problem here is that OnRefresh is again an async void method that can't be awaited but should be:
private async Task OnRefresh()
{
try
{
var trades = await ExchangeServiceInstance.GetTrades("");
mmTrades = new ObservableCollection<EEtrade>(trades);
tradeListView.ItemsSource = mmTrades;
}
catch { }
}
In your OnSignalReceived method change the call to OnRefresh(); to await OnRefresh();

Function as parameter in async method

I call a method containing a function:
public void DoMagicStuff(Func<T> anyfunction) {
// do lots of magic stuff
}
This works:
public void DoNonAsyncStuff() {
DoMagicStuff(()=> {
AnotherFunction();
}
}
While this does not:
public async Task<CustomClass> DoAsynStuff() {
DoMagicStuff(()=> {
return await DoSomethingDifferent();
}
}
"The await operator can only be used in async functions"
How do I make this work for async methods?

If you intend to pass asynchronous delegates to DoMagicStuff, then you need to overload that with an asynchronous version:
public void DoMagicStuff(Func<T> anyfunction)
{
// do lots of magic stuff
T t = anyfunction();
}
public async Task DoMagicStuff(Func<Task> asyncfunction)
{
// do lots of magic stuff
T t = await asyncfunction();
}
This allows you to call await for the asyncfunction.
Any common logic can always be refactored into another method.
With regard to your question, await can only be used in a function that has been declared async, which your lambda hasn't.
It should be like this:
public async Task<CustomClass> DoAsynStuff()
{
await DoMagicStuff(async () =>
{
return await DoSomethingDifferent();
});
}
And in fact, because DoSomethingDifferent already returns a Task, the lambda is superfluous:
public async Task<CustomClass> DoAsynStuff()
{
await DoMagicStuff(DoSomethingDifferent);
}

How to wait for async functions in c#

I have 3 async function that must run together, like this
public async Task Fun1()
{
// do something
}
public async Task Fun2()
{
// do something
}
public async Task Fun2()
{
// do something
}
in my base function I call this functions
this functions must run together
how to wait for this functions until all complete?
public async Task BaseFun()
{
Fun1()
Fun2()
Fun3()
// do something after Fun1, Fun2 and Fun3 complete
}

public async Task BaseFun()
{
await Task.WhenAll(Fun1(),
Fun2(),
Fun3());
// do something after Fun1, Fun2 and Fun3 complete
}

Just add await before the functions.
public async Task BaseFun()
{
await Fun1();
await Fun2();
await Fun3();
// do something after Fun1, Fun2 and Fun3 complete
}

also can do as
public async Task BaseFun()
{
await Fun1();
await Fun2();
await Fun3();
// do something after Fun1, Fun2 and Fun3 complete
}

You can also use Task.WaitAll.
var taskArray = new Task[3]
{
Fun1(),
Fun2(),
Fun3()
};
Task.WaitAll(taskArray);
BTW, why are your Fun1-3 methods also public when you call them through a public base method?

await not blocking until Task finishes

I am trying to block RequestHandler.ParseAll() with await ConsumerTask;, but when i set a breakpoint there, i ALWAYS get the "Done..." output first... and then Parse2() fails with a NullReferenceException. (thats my guess: "the GC starts cleaning up because _handler got out of scope")
Anyway, I can't figure out why that happens.
class MainClass
{
public async void DoWork()
{
RequestHandler _handler = new RequestHandler();
string[] mUrls;
/* fill mUrls here with values */
await Task.Run(() => _handler.ParseSpecific(mUrls));
Console.WriteLine("Done...");
}
}
static class Parser
{
public static async Task<IEnumerable<string>> QueryWebPage(string url) { /*Query the url*/ }
public static async Task Parse1(Query query)
{
Parallel.ForEach(/*Process data here*/);
}
public static async Task Parse2(Query query)
{
foreach(string line in query.WebPage)
/* Here i get a NullReference exception because query.WebPage == null */
}
}
sealed class RequestHandler
{
private BlockingCollection<Query> Queue;
private Task ConsumerTask = Task.Run(() => /* call consume() for each elem in the queue*/);
private async void Consume(Query obj)
{
await (obj.BoolField ? Parser.Parse1(obj) : Parser.Parse2(obj));
}
public async void ParseSpecific(string[] urls)
{
foreach(string v in urls)
Queue.Add(new Query(await QueryWebPage(v), BoolField: false));
Queue.CompleteAdding();
await ConsumerTask;
await ParseAll(true);
}
private async Task ParseAll(bool onlySome)
{
ReInit();
Parallel.ForEach(mCollection, v => Queue.Add(new Query(url, BoolField:false)));
Queue.CompleteAdding();
await ConsumerTask;
/* Process stuff further */
}
}
struct Query
{
public readonly string[] WebPage;
public readonly bool BoolField;
public Query(uint e, IEnumerable<string> page, bool b) : this()
{
Webpage = page.ToArray();
BoolField = b;
}
}

CodesInChaos has spotted the problem in comments. It stems from having async methods returning void, which you should almost never do - it means you've got no way to track them.
Instead, if your async methods don't have any actual value to return, you should just make them return Task.
What's happening is that ParseSpecific is only running synchronously until the first await QueryWebPage(v) that doesn't complete immediately. It's then returning... so the task started here:
await Task.Run(() => _handler.ParseSpecific(mUrls));
... completes immediately, and "Done" gets printed.
Once you've made all your async methods return Task, you can await them. You also won't need Task.Run at all. So you'd have:
public async void DoWork()
{
RequestHandler _handler = new RequestHandler();
string[] mUrls;
await _handler.ParseSpecific(mUrls);
Console.WriteLine("Done...");
}
...
public async TaskParseSpecific(string[] urls)
{
foreach(string v in urls)
{
// Refactored for readability, although I'm not sure it really
// makes sense now that it's clearer! Are you sure this is what
// you want?
var page = await QueryWebPage(v);
Queue.Add(new Query(page, false);
}
Queue.CompleteAdding();
await ConsumerTask;
await ParseAll(true);
}
Your Reinit method also needs changing, as currently the ConsumerTask will basically complete almost immediately, as Consume will return immediately as it's another async method returning void.
To be honest, what you've got looks very complex, without a proper understanding of async/await. I would read up more on async/await and then probably start from scratch. I strongly suspect you can make this much, much simpler. You might also want to read up on TPL Dataflow which is designed to make producer/consumer scenarios simpler.

c# Can a "task method" also be an "async" method?

I'm trying to get the hand of the new async CTP stuff and I'm probably confusing myself here..
I can have this "task method", with no problem:
public static Task<String> LongTaskAAsync() {
return Task.Run(() => {
return("AAA");
});
}
But what if I need the task to execute another task, can I mark it as "async" and use "await"? I tried this:
public async static Task<String> LongTaskAAsync() {
await Task.Delay(2000);
return Task.Run(() => {
return("AAA");
});
}
But then mysteriously get this compiler error: Since this is an async method, the return expression must be of type 'string' rather than Task<string>
What am I missing here?

You may want to read my async/await intro post.
Return values from async methods are wrapped in a Task<TResult>. Likewise, await unwraps those return values:
public static async Task<String> LongTaskAAsync() {
await Task.Delay(2000);
return await Task.Run(() => {
return("AAA");
});
}
The reasoning behind this is described in my Async "Why Do the Keywords Work That Way" Unofficial FAQ.
P.S. You can also use Task.FromResult for simple tests like this.
Edit: If you want to create and return the Task object itself, then the method should not be async. One somewhat common pattern is to have a public non-async method that calls the async portion only if necessary.
For example, some kind of asynchronous cache - if the object is in the cache, then return it immediately; otherwise, asynchronously create it, add it to the cache, and return it (this is example code - not thread-safe):
public static Task<MyClass> GetAsync(int key)
{
if (cache.Contains(key))
return Task.FromResult(cache[key]);
return CreateAndAddAsync(key);
}
private static async Task<MyClass> CreateAndAddAsync(int key)
{
var result = await CreateAsync(key);
cache.Add(key, result);
return result;
}

Can a “task method” also be an “async” method?
Yes it can be, by simply changing the method signature to public async static Task<Task<String>> LongTaskAAsync() since that is, what it will return.
If you use the async keyword, the runtime will wrap the type you return into a task, to enable asynchronousness. Say if you return a string, the runtime will wrap that into a Task<string>. int will go Task<int> and Task<string> will go Task<Task<string>>. See this console app to clearify:
public class Program
{
public static void Main(string[] args)
{
// start the main procedure asynchron
Task.Run(() => DoIt()).Wait();
}
// for async support since the static main method can't be async
public static async void DoIt()
{
Program p = new Program();
// use the methods
string s = await p.GetString();
int i = await p.GetInt();
Task<string> tsk = await p.GetTaskOfString();
// just to prove the task works:
// C# 5
string resultFromReturnedTask = await tsk;
// C# 4
string resultFromReturnedTask2 = tsk.Result;
}
public async Task<string> GetString()
{
return "string";
}
public async Task<int> GetInt()
{
return 6;
}
public async Task<Task<string>> GetTaskOfString()
{
return Task.Run(() => "string");
}
}