We Keep Coding

How to handle linq join query when join on id is not available in the table c#

I am not trying to join my table using left outer join in LINQ where one of my join conditions does not satisfy. How can I still get the default record in my dataset? My SQL query runs perfectly fine but my join query is not returning the data.
Below is my SQL query where my left outer join works fine:
select
w.issueid as Issue
from worklog w
join jiraissue as j on w.issueid=j.ID
join issuetype AS ty ON ty.ID = j.issuetype
join project AS p on p.ID=j.PROJECT
left outer join customfieldvalue cfv on cfv.ISSUE = w.issueid
Below is my LINQ query in C# where if cfv.issue in the last join is not available in the table, I want to still return the default column.
var data = (from w in worklogs
join i in issuetypes on j.issuetype equals i.ID
join p in projects on j.PROJECT equals p.ID into table0
from c in table0.DefaultIfEmpty()
join cfv in customfieldvalues on w.issueid equals cfv.ISSUE into table1
from d in table1.DefaultIfEmpty()
{
IssueKey = l.Key.pkey + '-' + l.Key.issuenum,
Hours = l.Sum(w => w.timeworked)
}).ToList();
Any help is appreciated.
Thank you.

Creating Linq from SQL with OrderBy and GroupBy

I have the following table structure.
TableA TableB TableC
- MID - PID - PID
- NAME - INIT_DATE - MID
This is the SQL Query that I need to translate into Linq
SELECT TOP 10 TableA.NAME,
COUNT(TableB.INIT_DATE) AS [TOTALCOUNT]
FROM TableC
INNER JOIN TableA ON TableC.MID = TableA.MID
LEFT OUTER JOIN TableB ON TableC.PID = TableB.PID
GROUP BY TableA.NAME
ORDER BY [TOTALCOUNT] DESC
I tried to reproduce the above query with this Linq query:
iqModel = (from tableC in DB.TableC
join tableA in DB.TableA on tableC.MID equals tableA.MID
select new { tableC, tableA } into TM
join tableB in DB.TableB on TM.tableC.PID equals J.PID into TJ
from D in TJ.DefaultIfEmpty()
select new { TM, D } into MD
group MD by MD.TM.tableA.NAME into results
let TOTALCOUNT = results.Select(item=>item.D.INIT_DATE).Count()
orderby TOTALCOUNT descending
select new SelectListItem
{
Text = results.Key.ToString(),
Value = TOTALCOUNT.ToString()
}).Take(10);
But I think I am doing something wrong.
The Output of the LINQ and SQL is not same. I think up to JOIN or GROUPBY it is Correct.
EDIT :-
I have also tried the following Linq query but still it's not working correctly.
var iqModel = (from c in DB.TableC
join a in DB.TableA on c.MID equals a.MID
join b in DB.b on c.PID equals b.PID into b_join
from b in b_join.DefaultIfEmpty()
select new SelectListItem { Text = a.NAME, Value = b.INIT_DATE != null ? b.INIT_DATE.ToString() : string.Empty });
var igModel = iqModel.GroupBy(item => item.Text);
var result = igModel.OrderByDescending(item => item.Select(r => r.Value).Count());
I want to understand what am I doing wrong and how can it be fixed.
I am newbie to LINQ to SQL I think in above LINQ I really made it complicated by adding more select.

I think the difference is caused by the fact that the SQL COUNT(field) function does not include NULL values. There is no direct equivalent construct in LINQ, but it could be simulated with Count(e => e.Field != null) or like this (which seems to produce better SQL):
var query =
(from a in db.TableA
join c in db.TableC on a.MID equals c.MID
join b in db.TableB on c.PID equals b.PID into joinB
from b in joinB.DefaultIfEmpty()
group b by a.Name into g
let TOTALCOUNT = g.Sum(e => e.INIT_DATE != null ? 1 : 0)
orderby TOTALCOUNT descending
select new SelectListItem { Text = g.Key, Value = TOTALCOUNT }
).Take(10);
which generates the following SQL
SELECT TOP (10)
[Project1].[C2] AS [C1],
[Project1].[Name] AS [Name],
[Project1].[C1] AS [C2]
FROM ( SELECT
[GroupBy1].[A1] AS [C1],
[GroupBy1].[K1] AS [Name],
1 AS [C2]
FROM ( SELECT
[Join2].[K1] AS [K1],
SUM([Join2].[A1]) AS [A1]
FROM ( SELECT
[Extent1].[Name] AS [K1],
CASE WHEN ([Extent3].[INIT_DATE] IS NOT NULL) THEN 1 ELSE 0 END AS [A1]
FROM [dbo].[TableAs] AS [Extent1]
INNER JOIN [dbo].[TableCs] AS [Extent2] ON [Extent1].[MID] = [Extent2].[MID]
LEFT OUTER JOIN [dbo].[TableBs] AS [Extent3] ON [Extent2].[PID] = [Extent3].[PID]
) AS [Join2]
GROUP BY [K1]
) AS [GroupBy1]
) AS [Project1]
ORDER BY [Project1].[C1] DESC

I assume, that you not see "group by" command at resulting query, instead of it "distinct" command is used. Am I right?
First query makes distinct by TableA.NAME and then calculates COUNT(TableB.INIT_DATE) with the help of subquery like this:
select distinct1.Name, (select count() from *join query* where Name = distinct1.Name)
from (select distinct Name from *join query*) as distinct1
If so, not worry about it. Because conversion from linq to real t-sql script sometimes very unpredictable (you can not force them to be equal, only when query is very simple), but both queries are equivalent one to another and return same results (compare them to make sure).

Inner Join Query incorrect result

Hi I am developing an application in VS 2010, C# and SQLCe database.
I am generating a report from 3 tables respectively Income, Expence and Transactions.
table structure is as below:
Income:
Expence:
Transactions:
For this I wrote query
select t.tDate as [Date], t.tDescription as [Detail],e.eAmount as [Debit],
i.iAmount as [Credit], t.balance as [Balance]
from Transactions t
inner join Expence e on t.pid=e.pid
join Income i on t.pid=i.pid
where t.pid='11'
But when I run this query I am just getting
I want that my result should be like a bank statement as below.
As per my understanding query is not right.
How can we write query to get result like this?

You must use the left join, not use Join. Because left return all cases in table from and case exists in table Expence e Income.
select t.tDate as [Date], t.tDescription as [Detail],e.eAmount as [Debit],
i.iAmount as [Credit], t.balance as [Balance]
from Transactions t
left join Expence e on t.pid=e.pid
left join Income i on t.pid=i.pid
where t.pid='11'

If I got it right to join items from Expence table with items from Transactions table you should use pId and eId and to join items from Income you should use pId and iId, so your select would look something like that:
select t.tDate as [Date], t.tDescription as [Detail],e.eAmount as [Debit],
i.iAmount as [Credit], t.balance as [Balance]
from Transactions t
inner join Expence e on t.pid=e.pid and t.eId = e.eId
join Income i on t.pid=i.pid and t.iId = i.iId
where t.pid='11'

EntityFramework generating poor tsql (linqpad generates much better)

I have a database structure as below
Family(1) ----- (*) FamilyPersons -----(1)Person(1)------() Expenses (1) -----(0..1)GroceriesDetails
Let me explain that relation, Family can have one or more than one person , we have a mapping table FamilyPersons between Family and Persons. Now each person can enter his expenses which go into Expenses Table. Expense Table has a column ExpenseType (groceries, entertainemnet etc)
and details of each of these expenses goes into their own Tables, so we have a GroceriesDetails table (similarly we have other tables), so we have 1 to 0..1 relation between Expense and Groceries.
Now I am writing a query to get Complete GroceriesDetails for a family
GroceriesDetails.Where (g => g.Expenses.Person.FamilyPersons.Any(fp =>
fp.FamilyId == 1) && g.Expenses.ExpenseType == "GC" )
For this the sql generated by EF is
SELECT
[Extent1].[Id] AS [Id],
[Extent1].[Amount] AS [Amount]
FROM [dbo].[GroceriesDetails] AS [Extent1]
INNER JOIN (SELECT [Extent3].[Id] AS [Id1]
FROM [dbo].[Expenses] AS [Extent2]
INNER JOIN [dbo].[GroceriesDetails] AS [Extent3] ON [Extent2].[Id] = [Extent3].[Id]
WHERE N'GC' = [Extent2].[ExpenseType] ) AS [Filter1] ON [Extent1].[Id] = [Filter1].[Id1]
WHERE EXISTS (SELECT
1 AS [C1]
FROM [dbo].[Expenses] AS [Extent4]
INNER JOIN [dbo].[GroceriesDetails] AS [Extent5] ON [Extent4].[Id] = [Extent5].[Id]
INNER JOIN [dbo].[FamilyPerson] AS [Extent6] ON [Extent4].[PersonId] = [Extent6].[PersonId]
WHERE ([Extent1].[Id] = [Extent5].[Id]) AND (1 = [Extent6].[FamilyId])
)
In this query there is a full table join between Expenses and GroceriesDetails tables which is causing performance issues.
Whereas Linqpad generates a much better SQL
SELECT [t0].[Id], [t0].[Amount]
FROM [GroceriesDetails] AS [t0]
INNER JOIN [Expenses] AS [t1] ON [t1].[Id] = [t0].[Id]
WHERE (EXISTS(
SELECT NULL AS [EMPTY]
FROM [Expenses] AS [t2]
INNER JOIN [Person] AS [t3] ON [t3].[Id] = [t2].[PersonId]
CROSS JOIN [FamilyPerson] AS [t4]
WHERE ([t4].[FamilyId] = #p0) AND ([t2].[Id] = [t0].[Id]) AND ([t4].[PersonId] =
[t3].[Id])
)) AND ([t1].[ExpenseType] = #p1)
Please note that we are using WCF data services so this query is written against a WCF data service reference, so I can't traverse from top (family) to bottom (Groceries) as OData allows only one level of select.
Any help on optimizing this code is appreciated.

From the comments I learned that LinqPad uses Linq2SQL while the app uses EF, and that explains the difference.
The thing is that you have zero control on how EF generates SQL.
The only thing you can do is to rewrite your LINQ query to make it "closer" to desired SQL.
For example, instead of
GroceriesDetails.Where (g => g.Expenses.Person.FamilyPersons.Any(fp => fp.FamilyId == 1)
&& g.Expenses.ExpenseType == "GC" )
you can try to write something like (pseudocode):
from g in GrosseriesDetails
join e in Expenses on g.Id = e.GrosseryId
join p in Persons on p.Id = e.PersonId
join f in FamilyPersons on f.PersonId = p.Id
where f.FamilyId == 1 && e.ExpenseType == "GC"
It almost always helps as it tells an ORM a straightforward way to transform it into SQL. The idea is that the expression tree in the "original" case is more complex compare to the proposed scenario, and by simplifying the expression tree we make translator's job easier and more straightforward.
But besides manipulating the LINQ there is no control over how it generates SQL from the expression tree.

How to convert following SQL Query into a LINQ to SQL query

I have following SQL Query and would like to convert to LINQ to SQL which I will use in entity framework 5.0
var internationalDesksList =
from internationalDesks in _context.InternationalDesks
from subsection in
_context.Subsections.Where(
s =>
internationalDesks.EBALocationId == s.LocationId ||
internationalDesks.FELocationId == s.LocationId).DefaultIfEmpty()
where subsection.PublicationId == 1
select new {internationalDesks.Id, subsection.LocationId};
I have referred the following posts and answers. Though no luck.
LINQ to SQL - Left Outer Join with multiple join conditions Linq
left join on multiple (OR) conditions
When I tried this query in LINQPad I got the following answer which is correct.
-- Region Parameters
DECLARE #p0 Int = 1
-- EndRegion
SELECT [t0].[Id], [t1].[Id] AS [Id1]
FROM [InternationalDesks] AS [t0]
LEFT OUTER JOIN [Subsection] AS [t1] ON (([t0].[FELocationId]) = [t1].[LocationId]) OR (([t0].[EBALocationId]) = [t1].[LocationId])
WHERE [t1].[PublicationId] = #p0
However in entity framework 5 ( DBContext ) it is not providing me with the correct query. When I checked in SQL profiler all columns in subsection table is selected. That's it.
Following is the result:
SELECT
[Extent1].[Id] AS [Id],
[Extent1].[Description] AS [Description],
[Extent1].[PracticeAreaId] AS [PracticeAreaId],
[Extent1].[LocationId] AS [LocationId],
...
FROM [dbo].[Subsection] AS [Extent1]
Don't know what could be problem. Please help me.

With LINQ you can't do LEFT OUTER JOIN on some boolean expression, only equijoins are supported. So, you can generate CROSS JOIN this way:
var internationalDesksList =
from internationalDesks in _context.InternationalDesks
from subsection in _context.Subsections
where subsection.PublicationId == 1 &&
(internationalDesks.EBALocationId == subsection.LocationId ||
internationalDesks.FELocationId == subsection.LocationId)
select new {
internationalDesks.Id,
subsection.LocationId
};
EF 5 will generate following SQL:
SELECT
[Extent1].[Id] AS [Id],
[Extent2].[LocationId] AS [LocationId]
FROM [dbo].[InternationalDesks] AS [Extent1]
CROSS JOIN [dbo].[Subsections] AS [Extent2]
WHERE (1 = [Extent2].[PublicationId]) AND
([Extent1].[EBALocationId] = [Extent2].[LocationId] OR
[Extent1].[FELocationId] = [Extent2].[LocationId])
As you can see, only required columns are selected. I also checked this query in LINQ to SQL - following query is generated:
DECLARE #p0 Int = 1
SELECT [t0].[Id], [t1].[LocationId]
FROM [InternationalDesks] AS [t0], [Subsections] AS [t1]
WHERE ([t1].[PublicationId] = #p0) AND
(([t0].[EBALocationId] = [t1].[LocationId]) OR
([t0].[FELocationId] = [t1].[LocationId]))